The substitution of gravel for sand, the commercialisation of an open-source invention, and the origins of the modern media-bed aquaponics industry.
Historical and technical investigation | October 2026
Introduction: The substitution that changed aquaponics history
In December 1989, Dr. Mark R. McMurtry introduced a group of agricultural practitioners to the Integrated Aqua-Vegeculture System (iAVs), a scientifically developed method of producing fish and vegetables using recirculating water and carefully selected sand.
Among those who encountered his work were Tom and Paula Speraneo, who subsequently established S&S AquaFarm near West Plains, Missouri.
McMurtry had spent years developing and investigating a system in which sand performed several essential functions simultaneously: growing plants, capturing suspended fish waste, supporting microbial nutrient conversion, retaining moisture and filtering water before its return to the fish tank.
The system had been designed to minimise equipment, water consumption, external fertilisers and operating expenses.
The Speraneos took a different approach.
They substituted coarse river gravel for the specified sand, modified the hydraulic arrangement and developed a system that they marketed as Bioponics.
They promoted their approach through articles, practical demonstrations, educational material, early internet discussion groups and commercially sold instructional packages.
Their adaptation became remarkably influential.
A United States Department of Agriculture-supported extension publication subsequently identified the Speraneo design as a model for numerous commercial aquaponics greenhouses and school programmes. Later aquaponics educators traced the development of the international backyard-aquaponics movement directly to their work.
The historical problem is that a modified version of an existing scientific invention became far more familiar than the original, while the important technical differences between sand and gravel were increasingly obscured.
This was not simply a change in growing medium. It was a change in how the system captured waste, retained moisture, processed nutrients and operated hydraulically.
And it helped create a commercial model in which practical knowledge, system designs, equipment and training could be marketed to an expanding audience.
1. The original invention: sand was fundamental to iAVs
McMurtry developed iAVs at North Carolina State University beginning in 1985.
The research involved an interdisciplinary team and a series of controlled investigations.
Its experimental programme included 16 independently operating systems arranged across four treatments with four replicates each.
The researchers investigated fish production, vegetable yields, water-use efficiency, nutrient assimilation and the relationship between fish-tank and growing-bed volumes.
The 1990 paper, Sand Culture of Vegetables Using Recirculated Aquacultural Effluents, documented successful integrated production without supplemental fertilisation under the reported experimental conditions.
The fundamental engineering principle was the use of properly graded sand as a multifunctional biological and physical medium.
Fish water containing suspended organic matter was applied directly to the sand beds.
The sand captured suspended particles while allowing water to pass through. Microorganisms associated with the sand, accumulated organic matter and plant roots participated in nutrient transformation and recycling.
The beds retained sufficient moisture to sustain plants between irrigation events.
After filtration, the water returned to the fish tanks.
The system operated through intermittent daytime irrigation rather than continuous circulation through the growing beds.
The sand was therefore central to the system’s engineering.
Its particle-size distribution, water-retention properties, filtration behaviour and biological environment were essential design considerations, not interchangeable details.
Replacing that medium with gravel meant changing the operating conditions on which the original experimental findings depended.
2. The 1989 workshop and McMurtry’s first-hand account
McMurtry describes meeting Tom and Paula Speraneo during a series of educational activities associated with the University of Arkansas and the Meadowcreek Project.
The December 1989 workshop introduced participants to iAVs and its operating principles.
In his letter to the FAO Director-General dated 20 April 2018, McMurtry recalled the Speraneos’ enthusiasm for the system.
He also described his disappointment when he learned that they had replaced the sand with gravel.
According to McMurtry, the substitution was justified by cost considerations, despite his advice that the specified sand was essential to the design.
His account states that the Speraneos continued developing and promoting their modified system despite his objections.
McMurtry regarded the decision as particularly damaging because he had deliberately made iAVs available for unrestricted public use.
He was willing to share the invention. His objection was that its essential engineering principles had been changed while its underlying concept was subsequently promoted under another identity.
From McMurtry’s perspective, the issue was not that someone adopted his open-source invention. It was that an altered system was being popularised without preserving the scientific principles that made the original work.
That distinction explains why the dispute became so persistent.
McMurtry had not simply published an idea. He and his colleagues had conducted experiments to establish how specific components should function together.
The Speraneos were entitled to experiment with alternative designs. Their modifications, however, required their own technical and scientific evaluation.
McMurtry’s 2018 first-hand account
3. The gravel substitution changed the system’s behaviour
A particularly valuable independent account appears in Steve Diver’s Aquaponics: Integration of Hydroponics with Aquaculture, published by the National Center for Appropriate Technology through its ATTRA agricultural extension programme.
Diver explicitly states that the Speraneos modified the North Carolina State University method.
He identifies the most important change: pea-grade river gravel replaced sand.
The publication also records changes to fish-tank placement, plumbing and water circulation.
This is an important independent confirmation of the technological lineage.
The Speraneo design originated as a modification of the NCSU approach, not as an unrelated invention.
Mechanical filtration
Sand and gravel behave differently when water containing suspended fish waste passes through them.
The smaller pore spaces between sand grains can capture finer suspended particles.
Coarse gravel contains larger voids, permitting more fine material to travel through the bed or accumulate in spaces between the stones.
Particle size, flow rate and bed depth influence how effectively either medium removes suspended material.
The distinction matters because retained solids contain nutrients that can become available to plants through microbial decomposition.
When a growing bed captures less of the fine particulate fraction, it also changes where organic matter accumulates and where mineralisation occurs.
Biological activity and mineralisation
Gravel can support beneficial bacteria, nitrification and the decomposition of trapped organic material.
Indeed, conventional media-bed aquaponics relies partly on those processes.
But replacing graded sand with coarse gravel changes the available surface area, pore structure, water distribution, organic-matter retention and biological environment.
The original NCSU research investigated a particular integrated sand-bed arrangement.
Its findings cannot simply be transferred to an altered gravel system.
The relevant scientific questions concern how much solid material each bed captures, how completely nutrients are recovered, how oxygen reaches the biological community and how these processes change over time.
Moisture retention and irrigation
Sand also retains moisture differently from coarse gravel.
Its capillary properties can maintain water around plant roots between irrigation events.
Coarse gravel generally provides less capillary moisture retention and drains more freely.
Consequently, the irrigation schedule developed for iAVs cannot automatically be used with gravel.
An altered medium may require changes in pumping frequency, flooding depth, water retention or bed drainage to keep the root zone adequately supplied.
The Speraneos redesigned their reciprocating water cycle, PVC plumbing and return-flow arrangements to suit their installation.
Later backyard aquaponics designs popularised automatically cycling flood-and-drain arrangements, including siphons.
The technical consequence was a growing divergence between the original intermittent sand-bed method and the increasingly familiar gravel-based systems.
A substitution intended to reduce the cost of one material changed multiple interconnected system requirements.
That is the central engineering criticism.
The 2014 FAO aquaponics manual itself acknowledges the importance of growing-medium particle size, noting that smaller particles provide denser packing and capture more suspended solids.
It also acknowledges the risk of accumulated waste creating clogged or oxygen-depleted areas in improperly balanced media beds.
These are the very considerations that make the original NCSU sand specifications important.
Steve Diver’s ATTRA publication, pages 4–7
FAO, Small-scale Aquaponic Food Production, 2014
4. What the Speraneos actually built
The original S&S AquaFarm installation began as a comparatively small integrated system.
Diver records a 500-gallon fish tank connected to gravel-cultured vegetable beds in a solar greenhouse.
The operation subsequently expanded into a commercial-scale greenhouse measuring approximately 50 by 80 feet.
Its developed arrangement contained six fish tanks, each with a capacity of approximately 1,200 gallons.
Each tank was connected to six hydroponic beds approximately one foot deep and filled with river gravel.
The individual fish-tank and bed assemblies operated as separate production units, referred to as nodes.
The farm grew basil, tomatoes, cucumbers, salad vegetables, herbs and ornamental plants.
It was a genuine productive installation.
The Speraneos also adapted the system to local conditions, including cooler-water tilapia hybrids and a commercial greenhouse arrangement.
These achievements explain why their design attracted attention.
However, a functioning commercial greenhouse does not establish that its operating principles are equivalent to the scientifically investigated NCSU design.
The Speraneos developed a different engineering arrangement, whose advantages and limitations needed to be established independently.
The nutrient-supplementation detail that matters
Diver’s technical account records that the Speraneos initially relied primarily on high-protein fish feed and tank-cultured algae.
Their fish feed reportedly contained 40% protein, compared with the 32% feed used in the original NCSU investigations.
Later, Tom Speraneo began applying Planters 2 rock dust to the gravel beds as a trace-element supplement.
This is a significant historical detail.
The gravel-based system eventually incorporated an additional mineral input, whereas the original NCSU trials had documented successful production without supplemental fertilisation.
The rock-dust addition does not, by itself, establish that the gravel system was nutritionally unsuccessful.
But it demonstrates that the modified design’s operating practices were not identical to those validated through the original sand-bed research.
Nor should the nutrient balances of systems using different feeds, fish stocking rates and operating schedules be treated as directly equivalent.
5. The birth of commercial “Bioponics”
The Speraneos promoted their system as Bioponics.
By the 1990s, the term appeared in articles, educational materials and internet discussions associated with their farm.
A December 1997 article by David Yarrow, published through Remineralize the Earth, was titled Bioponics—Revolution in Food Growing: Missouri Aquafarmer Discovers Huge Benefits in Trace Elements.
The terminology helped distinguish their installation from conventional hydroponics while creating a recognisable public identity around its biological production methods.
Yet the underlying concept was substantially indebted to the earlier NCSU research.
This is where scientific adaptation and commercial branding became intertwined.
McMurtry had worked to keep iAVs freely accessible.
The Speraneos developed a business that included producing food, demonstrating the modified system and selling instructions to people who wanted to construct similar installations.
They were not the first people to sell agricultural instructions, nor was charging for a manual inherently improper.
The historical significance is that a commercially distributed version of the technology acquired an identity and audience distinct from the research on which it was based.
The $250 information package
Diver records that S&S AquaFarm sold a resource package containing a design manual, technical specifications, supply information and a ten-minute instructional video.
The listed price in the 2006 ATTRA publication was US$250.
Earlier accounts place the price at approximately US$200, although the original earlier price list has not been located.
The documented $250 offering confirms that the farm was selling access to its system-specific construction knowledge.
The system’s popularity was substantial.
Diver reported more than 10,000 visitors to the farm, including farmers, students, scientists and government officials.
The publication also described its influence on numerous commercial greenhouses and educational installations.
This is direct historical evidence of how the modified technology spread.
An open-source university invention had inspired a design that became a marketable educational product, and that product helped spread a different version of the original technology.
The price of the manual was less important than the growing separation between public familiarity with the modified design and familiarity with the original experimental record.
6. The internet turned a local adaptation into an international movement
The Speraneos were early participants in online agricultural information sharing.
A particularly important primary source survives from 4 December 1997.
In a message to an internet permaculture mailing list, Paula Speraneo announced a dedicated aquaponics discussion group.
The message invited people interested in combined aquaculture and hydroponics to subscribe and share information.
It identified Tom and Paula Speraneo as the group’s providers and gave the contact details for S&S AquaFarm.
This is direct documentary evidence of the role the couple played in establishing early online aquaponics communities.
Unlike a later historical summary, the message dates the activity precisely.
Their online influence would become an important part of the subsequent growth of backyard aquaponics.
Paula Speraneo’s original mailing-list announcement, 4 December 1997
The Australian connection
The next stage is documented by Sylvia Bernstein in the published preface to her book Aquaponic Gardening.
Bernstein describes the Speraneos’ Missouri operation and their early internet mailing list as important starting points for the modern backyard-aquaponics movement.
She specifically identifies Australian entrepreneur Joel Malcolm as someone who discovered the Speraneo discussion list while researching aquaponics during the early 2000s.
Malcolm subsequently experimented with backyard systems, established Backyard Aquaponics and developed educational publications, forums and equipment sales.
Murray Hallam’s Practical Aquaponics business became another influential participant in Australia’s rapidly expanding aquaponics sector.
Bernstein describes the development of her own business, The Aquaponic Source, which brought education, online communities and aquaponics products together.
Her account establishes a clear historical transmission:
The Speraneos’ Missouri operation helped inspire an international network of backyard system builders, educators, equipment suppliers and commercial promoters.
The original iAVs research occupied a much less prominent position in the public version of that history.
The modified gravel approach became familiar to ordinary aquaponics hobbyists, while the original sand-bed methodology was frequently overlooked or treated as a historical precursor rather than a distinct, scientifically investigated technology.
Published preface to Sylvia Bernstein’s Aquaponic Gardening
7. How the gravel pivot influenced the aquaponics marketplace
The commercial consequences extended beyond the sale of one information package.
Backyard aquaponics developed into an industry offering prefabricated systems, growing media, tanks, pumps, plumbing, siphons, aeration equipment, water-testing instruments, biological additives, nutrient supplements, training and consultancy.
Gravel and expanded-clay media beds became familiar design choices.
The equipment industry did not arise solely from the Speraneos. It incorporated contributions from multiple researchers, manufacturers and commercial operators.
Nevertheless, their design was an important early template for the non-UVI media-bed branch.
The economic distinction matters.
An authentic iAVs installation relies on properly graded sand performing several treatment and growing functions simultaneously.
Other designs distribute those responsibilities differently or use different media, requiring their own management and operating arrangements.
Some gravel systems work without separate biological filters. Others use additional filtration or solids-management components.
The development of additional equipment can offer legitimate practical benefits.
But each component also has a purchase price, maintenance requirement and potential point of failure.
When a technology is intended for people with limited resources, those costs must be justified through actual improvements in production, reliability or operating efficiency.
The aquaponics industry’s commercial success cannot be treated as evidence that its dominant equipment choices are the most resource-efficient choices available.
That requires comparative research.
The original NCSU sand-bed system deserved precisely that kind of evaluation.
Instead, the historically influential gravel adaptation spread primarily through practical demonstrations, educational publications, personal experience and commercial promotion.
The issue is not that experimentation by growers is illegitimate.
It is that widespread adoption does not confer the experimental validation of a different system.
8. The missing scientific comparison
This is the central scientific weakness in the historical story.
The NCSU programme investigated component ratios, water quality, fish production, crop yields and nutrient recovery using independent experimental systems.
The Speraneo approach was developed through practical adaptation and commercial greenhouse operation.
Its history includes substantial experience and useful observational findings.
But the original documentation does not establish a controlled, replicated whole-system comparison demonstrating that the gravel adaptation equalled or exceeded authentic iAVs in nutrient recovery, water consumption, electricity demand, labour requirements, long-term reliability or food production.
That matters because changing the medium altered multiple linked processes.
The appropriate experiment would have compared complete systems operating under equivalent fish-feeding, stocking, crop, water and environmental conditions, with independently replicated installations.
Such research could have measured the actual effects of the media substitution.
It could have established whether cheaper initial media justified any differences in pumping, nutrient retention, cleaning and maintenance.
It could also have identified which design was more suitable for resource-poor communities.
Instead, practical success and widespread adoption helped establish gravel beds as a conventional aquaponics method without resolving the fundamental comparative question.
The growing popularity of the modified system should have stimulated more research into the original sand-based approach.
It should not have helped push the original methodology into obscurity.
9. McMurtry’s objection was about scientific integrity
McMurtry’s frustration with the Speraneo adaptation is well documented.
In his 2012 public discussion titled Tracking Reality, he challenged a widely circulated account crediting the Speraneos with pioneering home-based aquaponics.
He objected to the omission of NCSU, iAVs and his own contribution.
His criticism was blunt, including the allegation that the Speraneos had taken the method from him personally, changed its growing medium and subsequently received recognition for the resulting design.
McMurtry’s statements must be understood in the context of his involvement in the original invention and his direct dealings with the couple.
He was not a distant commentator assessing an unfamiliar system.
He was the inventor whose experimental research the modified approach had drawn upon.
His grievance concerned the alteration of an engineered system, the loss of its original identity and the subsequent public allocation of credit.
The point is especially significant because iAVs was deliberately released for free use.
McMurtry had no objection to people building the original system.
He wanted that to happen.
His objection was that important design changes had been popularised while the scientific work explaining why the original components mattered was neglected.
The continuing distinction between iAVs and conventional gravel-bed aquaponics reflects that concern.
McMurtry’s 2012 public discussion, Tracking Reality
10. The larger consequence: a generation learned the adaptation before the invention
By the 2000s, modern backyard aquaponics had become strongly associated with gravel and expanded-clay growing beds, fish tanks, pumps and flood-and-drain cycles.
Educational courses and equipment suppliers promoted systems descended from numerous practical designs, including the Speraneo approach.
For many practitioners, these systems represented aquaponics itself.
The original NCSU research became less visible.
Yet iAVs had already demonstrated that fish waste could be processed through a carefully designed sand-bed system that integrated mechanical filtration, biological activity, horticultural production and intermittent irrigation.
The historical consequence was a distorted understanding of what had actually been developed and tested.
People learned that media beds formed an important branch of aquaponics.
They were less likely to learn that the particular choice of sand in the NCSU design was supported by years of experimental investigation.
They encountered commercially promoted equipment and construction methods while the original open-source research remained comparatively obscure.
That imbalance matters because technological development is cumulative.
Researchers and growers build upon the information they encounter.
When the widely disseminated version differs substantially from the original, later research may concentrate on improving the modified system rather than examining the earlier design decisions.
In that way, an apparently minor historical omission can influence decades of engineering development, commercial purchasing decisions and educational practice.
Conclusion: the cost of replacing science with familiarity
Tom and Paula Speraneo contributed to the popularisation of aquaponics.
They developed a functioning commercial greenhouse, shared practical knowledge, established early online communities and helped inspire subsequent system builders.
Their influence is independently documented.
But the historical record also establishes that their design was a modification of earlier NCSU work.
They replaced sand with river gravel, altered the hydraulic arrangement, developed a distinct commercial identity and distributed instructions through paid information packages.
These changes were consequential.
They affected filtration, nutrient retention, moisture management and the operating conditions investigated in the original research.
The Speraneo system became an influential practical and commercial template.
What it did not acquire through popularity was the scientific validation of the original iAVs methodology.
That is the central distinction the modern aquaponics industry has too often failed to preserve.
McMurtry and his collaborators had invested years in investigating the biological and engineering relationships that made their system work.
The Speraneos developed a different version and promoted it successfully.
Over time, the modified approach became more familiar to the public than the original.
The resulting commercial ecosystem expanded through publications, equipment sales, courses, consultancy and international online communities.
The scientific question should always have remained straightforward: did the modification improve performance, reduce costs or make the system more appropriate for its intended users?
That question required controlled comparisons and complete accounting of operating conditions.
The greatest historical failure was allowing widespread adoption of the modified system to stand in for those comparisons, while the original sand-bed research received far less recognition than it deserved.
For McMurtry, the consequences were personal.
An invention he had deliberately made available to the world was transformed into a widely promoted alternative whose public identity increasingly obscured its origins.
For agricultural research, the consequences were potentially much greater.
Decades of growers, researchers and development organisations became familiar with gravel-based aquaponics while an extensively investigated sand-based technology remained underrepresented.
And for communities needing affordable food production, the distinction between those technologies was anything but academic.
Every unnecessary expense, operating requirement or lost opportunity for nutrient recovery matters when resources are scarce.
The Speraneo gravel pivot therefore deserves recognition as a major turning point in aquaponics history.
It demonstrates how a successful commercial adaptation can overtake the original scientific invention in public recognition—and how easily technical differences disappear when marketing, familiarity and repetition become more influential than the research record.
The history of iAVs is not complete until that distinction is restored.
Principal sources
McMurtry, M. R., Nelson, P. V., Sanders, D. C., and Hodges, L. (1990). Sand Culture of Vegetables Using Recirculated Aquacultural Effluents. Applied Agricultural Research, 5(4), 280–284. Original scientific publication.
Diver, S. (2006). Aquaponics: Integration of Hydroponics with Aquaculture. ATTRA, National Center for Appropriate Technology. Pages 4–7 contain the original NCSU and Speraneo descriptions, the gravel substitution, supplementation, international adoption and $250 information package. Original extension publication.
Speraneo, P. (1997). Aquaponics/Bioponics Mail Group. Original internet mailing-list announcement, 4 December 1997. Archived message.
Yarrow, D. (1997). Bioponics—Revolution in Food Growing: Missouri Aquafarmer Discovers Huge Benefits in Trace Elements. Remineralize the Earth, December 1997. Identified in the ATTRA bibliography.
McMurtry, M. R. (2018). Letter to FAO Director-General José Graziano da Silva, 20 April. Primary-source testimony concerning the Speraneo workshop, gravel substitution and subsequent dissemination. Historical letter.
McMurtry, M. R. (2012). Contributions to Tracking Reality, Aquaponic Gardening discussion forum. Original discussion.
Bernstein, S. (2011). Aquaponic Gardening: A Step-by-Step Guide to Raising Vegetables and Fish Together. New Society Publishers. Preface documents the Speraneo mailing list, Joel Malcolm, Murray Hallam and the emergence of commercial backyard aquaponics. Publisher’s excerpt.
Somerville, C., Cohen, M., Pantanella, E., Stankus, A., and Lovatelli, A. (2014). Small-scale Aquaponic Food Production. FAO Fisheries and Aquaculture Technical Paper 589. Official FAO publication.
Lama, L., and colleagues (2025). Recent Advances in Aquaponic Systems: A Critical Review. Reviews in Aquaculture. Discusses biological filtration, media-bed mineralisation and operating problems associated with solids accumulation. Journal publication.
