The most significant discovery is a precise date supplied by Murray Hallam himself. His own Practical Aquaponics newsletter, published on 9 February 2021, states that he had built his first iAVs installation 22 months earlier.
That places construction around April 2019, with the alleged onset of fish mortality at 18 months falling around October 2020.
This is important because Hallam was still publicly endorsing the technology in February 2021, reporting successful operation and advertising an opportunity for paying students to inspect the sand-bed systems.
His later account says plant deterioration had already begun at 12–15 months and fish deaths at 18 months. His earlier account made no mention of either problem.
The difference is documented in two directly comparable sources: Hallam’s own 9 February 2021 newsletter and his statements of 12 August 2022 and 25 January 2025, preserved in the subsequent documentary archive.
1. Reconstructing the timeline from Hallam’s own dates
| Date | What Hallam reported |
|---|---|
| April 2019, approximately | First iAVs system constructed, according to the February 2021 newsletter |
| November 2019 | Growing With Fishes Podcast 179 discusses the early experiment, then around 4–5 months old |
| April–July 2020 | Period when plant health supposedly began deteriorating, according to his 2025 account |
| October 2020 | Approximate beginning of fish deaths, based on his later 18-month claim |
| 9 February 2021 | Publicly reports successful systems and encourages wider adoption; promotes sand beds at his March Master Class |
| Around 22 months of operation | In the recorded discussion with Stephen Raisner, reports excellent tomatoes, stable pH and happy fish |
| 12 August 2022 | Announces shutdown after a stated 2.5 years; suspects silica nanoparticles; laboratory tests outstanding |
| 25 January 2025 | Claims fish deaths began at 18 months, describes silicosis as discovered, disputes earlier claims of pH stability |
The April 2019 construction date is grounded in Hallam’s own written statement. The exact recording date of the separate 22-month interview has not yet been independently established, so it should not be assigned a calendar date merely because the iAVs website republished the transcript in 2025.
The November 2019 podcast and the later 22-month interview are also distinct recordings. Confusing their dates would distort the chronology.
2. The 18-month fish-death claim against the 22-month success report
This is the most important comparison.
In his later account, dated 25 January 2025, Hallam claimed that plant health had deteriorated after 12–15 months and fish began dying around 18 months.
Yet during his positive 22-month report, he described the sand installation as an unusually successful example of the technology. The recording with Stephen Raisner contains these statements:
“we’re finally getting fantastic results out of that.”
He also said:
“The fish are happy.”
Hallam went on to describe 125 mature jade perch, impressive tomato production, minimal maintenance and a system that worked extremely well. He did not disclose fish mortality, declining plant health or an unresolved problem with the growing medium.
iAVs
Compare that with his January 2025 statement:
“We found we started having fish deaths from about 18 months on.”
He also described plant health declining from 12–15 months and the fish subsequently dying.
iAVs
The issue is not merely a discrepancy of four months.
At 22 months, Hallam was discussing precisely the things that would have exposed the alleged problem: the system’s maturity, long-term stability, fish health, plant production and the reliability of McMurtry’s research.
He presented the installation as evidence of success.
Four years later, he described the same period as one in which the system had already begun deteriorating and fish had started dying.
Both descriptions could refer to real observations if some fish died while others remained healthy. But that possibility does not explain the complete omission of the reported mortality and plant decline from a detailed public assessment of system performance.
The unresolved question is whether the 22-month report gave its audience an accurate account of the problems then known to the operator.
3. A second, independently dated positive statement
The 9 February 2021 newsletter establishes that Hallam’s enthusiasm was not confined to an undated video.
He wrote that his systems were operating successfully, that he had seen great results and that the method deserved wider adoption.
Crucially, he also announced:
“At this coming Aquaponics Master Class, which will start on the 1st March 2021, we will feature our Sand Bed Systems.”
That announcement came approximately four months after the fish deaths supposedly began.
He was inviting students to inspect the technology and learn about its benefits. The newsletter discussed ammonia accumulation as a potential operating issue, but contained no warning about unexplained fish deaths, deterioration beginning months earlier or possible silica toxicity.
ARCHIVE
This is stronger evidence than the absence of an incidental remark in a video. It is a dated, written communication promoting the same experimental technology to prospective students.
4. The shutdown dates introduce another discrepancy
Hallam’s newsletter says his first iAVs installation was built approximately April 2019.
His August 2022 statement says the system had been shut down after 2.5 years of operation.
Thirty months from April 2019 is approximately October 2021. But his shutdown announcement was made in August 2022, approximately 40 months after construction.
There is therefore a ten-month difference between the system’s age at the date of the announcement and the operating duration he reported.
That discrepancy could reflect a shutdown months before the Facebook announcement, a different experimental installation or approximate recollection. The sources examined do not identify which explanation applies.
The January 2025 account introduced yet another description, calling the experiment a two-year trial.
Thus Hallam publicly described the programme as approximately two years old in February 2021, operating for 2.5 years in the 2022 closure account, and a two-year trial in 2025.
A dated installation register and shutdown record would establish exactly which system and period each statement refers to.
5. Hallam contradicted his earlier account of pH stability
The pH issue is especially revealing because it involves direct assertions about the performance of McMurtry’s original technology.
In the positive interview, Hallam said McMurtry’s prediction that the system would stabilise was proving correct:
“Our pH is settled to about 6.4.”
He stated that no pH adjustments were necessary and described the stability of the installation as confirmation of the original research.
But in January 2025, Hallam said:
“Another claim in the McMurtry papers is that system pH stabilises, but we did not find that to be true.”
These are opposing descriptions of the system’s stability.
iAVs
+1
Water chemistry can change over time. A system that was stable during one period may become unstable during another.
But Hallam’s later categorical rejection of pH stability omitted his own earlier report that it had occurred at approximately 6.4 without correction.
A fair account of his experiment would document both periods, including the dates and measurements showing when stability was achieved and when it was lost.
Instead, the public received a favourable description followed years later by an apparently contrary one.
6. The silica explanation changed from suspicion to apparent certainty
The wording of Hallam’s two later accounts is another major warning sign.
On 12 August 2022, he stated:
“We are yet to get lab tests done”
He described silica nanoparticles as the suspected explanation and acknowledged that the precise problem had not been established.
On 25 January 2025, he stated:
“After several months, we discovered the problem of Silicosis.”
He attributed fish deaths to microbial and fungal activity releasing silica from sand.
iAVs
The language changed from suspicion to discovery.
That development would ordinarily be supported by new findings: laboratory measurements, examination of the affected fish, documentation of the mechanism or another identifiable diagnostic investigation.
None was supplied alongside the reproduced statements.
The original archive also preserves an exchange in which another participant asked whether silicosis had been identified through a fish autopsy.
Hallam replied that he had been surprised and referred to the Canadian experiment. His answer did not identify a veterinary laboratory, pathology report, diagnostic method or measurement establishing the diagnosis.
The critical question is straightforward: What evidence was obtained between August 2022 and January 2025 that transformed the silica hypothesis into a claimed discovery?
The documented public statements do not answer it.
7. Hallam invoked other investigations without identifying their evidence
In 2022, Hallam claimed that several trout farms using sand filters had experienced similar problems.
In 2025, he claimed that an experimental installation in Canada had corroborated his findings.
These are two separate attempts to support his explanation through outside experience.
The first invokes supposedly recorded incidents in commercial aquaculture. The second invokes another system whose operators allegedly arrived at the same conclusion.
However, the recovered statements provide no named trout facilities, case reports, measured silica concentrations or veterinary diagnoses.
Similarly, the Canadian system is not identified in the quoted exchange by a published experimental report or fish pathology record.
This matters because independent corroboration requires more than another operator encountering similar symptoms. The cause must also be established independently.
The claims concerning both the trout farms and Canadian installation remain identifiable elements of Hallam’s public explanation. Their underlying records have not been obtained through this investigation.
8. Hallam’s criticism of McMurtry’s research can be checked directly
This is the clearest factual error that can be resolved through independent published evidence.
In January 2025, Hallam asserted:
“Dr. McMurtry only ran his systems for 6+ months”
He used the claimed brevity of the original research to explain why McMurtry supposedly failed to encounter the long-term problems Hallam reported.
iAVs
But the published scientific record contradicts that description of the overall research programme.
McMurtry, Sanders, Cure and Hodson’s Effects of Biofilter/Culture Tank Volume Ratios on Productivity of a Recirculating Fish/Vegetable Co-Culture System, published in the Journal of Applied Aquaculture in 1997, documents three experiments conducted over one year.
The experiments included summer 1988 tomatoes, a fall 1988 cucumber phase and spring 1989 tomatoes. The researchers examined four biofilter-to-tank ratios and measured fish production, water chemistry and plant performance.
Taylor & Francis Online
+2
The wider NCSU research programme continued across several years, with additional publications and investigations.
A particular crop experiment may have lasted several months. That cannot reasonably be used to describe the duration of the entire research programme.
Hallam was familiar with the original research. He had publicly acknowledged possessing McMurtry’s papers for approximately a decade and praised their findings.
His 2025 criticism should therefore be compared with the actual publications rather than accepted as an accurate summary of them.
9. What Hallam’s own video reveals about the installation
During the 22-month presentation, Hallam reported approximately 35 m² of sand-bed growing area and 125 mature jade perch weighing around two pounds each.
That represents approximately 113 kg of standing fish biomass.
He also described irrigation lasting 12 minutes every 90 minutes during daylight, with pumping stopped overnight.
iAVs
These details provide a starting point for examining the installation independently.
At the original iAVs design relationship of approximately 6 m² of bed per 1,000 litres of tank water, 35 m² would correspond to a tank of approximately 5,833 litres. At that volume, 113 kg of fish would represent approximately 19.4 kg/m³.
That is a conditional calculation, not an independently measured stocking density for Hallam’s system. His actual operating tank volume, feed rate and water-quality measurements must be established before interpreting the consequences.
The video, however, makes clear that the experiment was not simply a container of fish connected to inert sand. It was a biological system whose performance depended on fish biomass, feeding, water chemistry, drainage and plant nutrient uptake.
Hallam’s 2025 explanation attributed the deaths to the medium. The recovered explanation does not document the elimination of oxygen depletion, ammonia toxicity, nitrite exposure, disease or other causes.
That is the principal problem with drawing a general conclusion about iAVs from this installation.
10. The independent scientific record on silica
The term silicosis has a specific established meaning.
The US National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health describes it as a lung disease caused by inhalation of respirable crystalline silica. It is associated with airborne exposure, not simply contact with quartz sand.
CDC
Scientific research also documents that microorganisms can weather quartz surfaces. A 2005 study by Brehm and colleagues examined biologically induced changes to quartz and glass.
ScienceDirect
Separately, a 2021 study found tissue damage in Nile tilapia exposed to manufactured silica nanoparticles at concentrations of 20, 40 and 100 mg/L.
PMC
These findings establish two relevant facts: biological quartz weathering can occur, and particular silica nanoparticles can harm fish under experimental exposure conditions.
They do not establish that Hallam’s sand produced toxic nanoparticles, that his fish encountered harmful concentrations, or that such exposure caused his reported deaths.
That causal chain requires evidence specific to his installation.
The scientific challenge to Hallam is therefore precise: demonstrate the particles, demonstrate exposure and demonstrate the resulting pathology.
An allegation of silicosis does not accomplish those steps.
11. The commercial-interest question deserves serious examination
Your proposed explanation concerns the potential conflict between Hallam’s established aquaponics business and the implications of adopting a simpler, earlier technology.
There is substantial documentary evidence of the commercial interests involved.
Practical Aquaponics describes itself as a supplier of equipment, system designs, education, books, DVDs, consultations and training. Its website claims hundreds of installed kits and exports to several countries.
Australia Aquaponics Supplies
The February 2021 newsletter advertised products alongside Hallam’s favourable discussion of iAVs.
At that time, the advertised offerings included a one-hour consultation with Hallam for A$170, Indy 23 system plans for A$395 and a fibreglass grow bed for A$847.
It also promoted an upcoming commercial Master Class that would feature the sand-based installation.
ARCHIVE
This establishes a long-standing educational and equipment-sales business operating alongside his experiments.
Hallam acknowledged a fundamental limitation of conventional aquaponics
His own newsletter contains a particularly important admission.
He explained that conventional aquaponics frequently requires mineral supplementation because fish waste does not provide sufficient nutrients for all crops.
He even acknowledged the emergence of businesses specialising in diagnosing nutrient deficiencies and providing supplementation.
Hallam contrasted this with iAVs, saying its reported ability to operate without supplementation was what originally attracted him to the technology.
That is an extraordinary commercial and technical contrast coming from an established aquaponics educator.
He was openly describing a method that potentially simplified the nutrient-management problems encountered in systems taught throughout the existing industry.
His remarks about the difficulty of writing a book
The 22-month interview offers another revealing comparison.
After describing the technology as extremely simple, Hallam remarked:
“It’s can be a bit difficult to write a book about actually.”
The wording is taken from the archived transcript.
iAVs
In January 2025, he explained that he would no longer produce the proposed iAVs eBook because his experiment had proved unsatisfactory.
The two statements belong to different stages of his assessment, but they illustrate the educational implications of the technology.
In the earlier account, simplicity was a major attraction. In the later account, the experimental outcome became the reason not to publish the proposed instructional material.
12. Could accepting iAVs have threatened his existing career and business?
This is a legitimate hypothesis arising from the documented commercial history.
Hallam had built an international reputation teaching aquaponics before publicly experimenting with iAVs.
His existing teaching and product catalogue centred on aquaponics systems, growing beds, pumps, plumbing, filtration and associated equipment.
He subsequently encountered a technology developed decades earlier that, by his own account, offered lower electricity consumption, fewer nutrient additions and simpler operation.
That creates a potential professional dilemma.
An established educator who adopts a substantially different methodology must decide how to explain the earlier recommendations, distinguish the technologies and present the advantages of the newer approach without diminishing confidence in the education already sold.
For an educator whose reputation is closely associated with a particular technological tradition, that process may involve substantial professional and commercial adjustment.
McMurtry explicitly raised the financial-motivation theory in a comment dated 21 October 2024, preserved beneath the archived Hallam interview. He alleged that Hallam’s interest in iAVs had increased as income from his established approach declined. He also criticised Hallam for continuing to modify the original methodology according to his existing assumptions.
iAVs
That is McMurtry’s recorded assessment, not an independently established account of Hallam’s finances.
There are two important facts to retain alongside the hypothesis.
First, Hallam demonstrably had commercial interests associated with conventional aquaponics.
Second, he also openly endorsed iAVs in 2021 and promoted its inclusion in his own paid training. He was not consistently hostile to the technology.
The evidence therefore supports examining whether commercial interests influenced his later rejection. It does not establish his private motivation or show that the earlier courses, equipment and expertise had become worthless.
The more revealing question is whether Hallam’s 2025 rejection was supported by experimental findings strong enough to justify overturning the conclusions he had publicly promoted in 2021.
13. The distinction between iAVs and commercial aquaponics
There is a further historical dimension to the possible conflict.
McMurtry has repeatedly described iAVs as an integrated agricultural and organic horticultural methodology, rather than simply another form of modern commercial aquaponics.
The original system uses graded sand as a combined growing medium, solids-processing environment and biological filter, with intermittent irrigation supplying fish-derived nutrients directly to the plant root environment.
Hallam’s 2021 newsletter used the terms iAVs, Sand Ponics and Sand Gardening interchangeably, presenting the technology as an alternative within the broader aquaponics industry.
His positive interview went further, suggesting it could change the future of aquaponics.
The terminology reflects a genuine difference in how the original inventor and later commercial educators have framed the technology.
Adopting iAVs as a distinct methodology could require an educator to revisit more than particular components. It could require explaining the scientific history, the original research priorities and the differences between that research and the commercial systems popularised later.
That is another reason the historical relationship matters when evaluating the industry response.
14. The role of Stephen Raisner and the circulation of the claim
Stephen Raisner’s role deserves separate attention because he was involved at both ends of the public chronology.
He interviewed Hallam during the period when the experimental sand system was presented positively.
The recorded discussion included the 22-month performance report, stable pH, healthy fish and the suggestion that sand-based cultivation might substantially change aquaponics.
The material examined shows no challenge from Raisner during that interview concerning fish mortality or worsening plant health.
The supplied archival register then records Raisner repeating the later fish-silicosis explanation on the Aquaponics Association forum in January 2026.
The archived wording is:
“Murray gave up sandponics after the fish got silicosis from the sand beds”
The forum’s original message was not independently retrieved during this investigation, so the quotation remains grounded in the supplied archive.
Its significance is the progression from one operator’s account of an experimental failure to another educator’s presentation of the proposed diagnosis.
The same network had previously publicised the system’s strengths.
The question for the historical record is whether the later criticism was subjected to the same level of examination as the earlier claims of success.
Raisner was in a position to compare the later allegation with the earlier interview because he had personally participated in discussing the experiment’s performance.
15. What an independently accountable explanation would contain
Hallam told his audience in the earlier interview that records were being maintained.
That statement is important because the central discrepancies could be examined against contemporaneous operating records rather than reconstructed from later recollections.
Those records would establish the actual dates of plant deterioration and individual fish deaths, the numbers and sizes of fish affected, the relevant water-quality measurements, whether more than one installation was involved, and the date on which each experiment ceased operating.
The same documentation could identify when the previously reported pH stability changed and what laboratory investigation led Hallam to adopt the silica explanation.
It would also distinguish an apparent fish-health diagnosis from a hypothesis shared between collaborating operators.
For an allegation invoking silica nanoparticles and a named pathological condition, the decisive materials would include the diagnostic findings and the evidence connecting the suspected particles to the observed mortality.
These are not extraordinary scientific demands. They are the ordinary records needed to investigate an experimental animal mortality event.
16. Findings of the investigation
The strongest directly established findings concern the dates and Hallam’s own words.
He stated in February 2021 that the first installation had been built approximately 22 months earlier, placing its construction around April 2019.
His later account therefore places the onset of plant decline around April–July 2020 and fish deaths around October 2020.
Yet in February 2021, he published a favourable assessment, encouraged adoption and promoted the sand beds for an upcoming commercial Master Class.
His 22-month recorded presentation likewise described successful tomato production, stable pH, healthy fish and minimal maintenance.
In August 2022, he attributed declining production to suspected silica nanoparticles while acknowledging that laboratory tests remained outstanding.
In January 2025, he described silicosis as a discovered problem, attributed fish deaths to microbial degradation of sand, and rejected pH stability that he had previously claimed to observe.
He also characterised McMurtry’s research as lasting approximately six months, although the independently published research documents a multi-year programme, including three experiments conducted over one year.
These are substantial discrepancies in a public technical account.
The sources also show the commercial context: Hallam had an established business selling aquaponics equipment, education and consultations, and he recognised iAVs as a comparatively simple method that potentially avoided some conventional nutrient-management problems.
The financial-conflict hypothesis is therefore relevant to understanding the circumstances surrounding his changing public position.
The cause of his reported fish deaths, however, remains a separate technical question that the recovered statements do not resolve.
บทสรุป
The problem exposed by this investigation is not simply that an experienced aquaponics operator suffered an unsuccessful experiment.
It is that he publicly offered markedly different descriptions of the same experimental programme, including its duration, the onset of deterioration, fish health, pH stability and the ultimate cause of failure.
The most important date comes directly from Hallam: the first system was already 22 months old in February 2021.
That places his later allegations of plant decline and fish mortality inside a period when he was publicly celebrating the system and encouraging others to adopt it.
His own records, if preserved, would provide the most direct means of resolving the discrepancy.
Until those records and the claimed diagnostic findings are placed alongside his public statements, the historical evidence demonstrates a significant gap between what Hallam reported during the experiment and what he subsequently told his audience had happened.
The public deserves an accurate account of both. An educator’s reputation should never be a substitute for the records of the experiment he asks people to believe.