A 2026 review by Baldoni et al. identifies potential benefits of biochar but provides no experimental evidence that it improves the original NCSU iAVs design. It also reports contradictory outcomes, including nutrient imbalances, elevated electrical conductivity, altered pH, reduced growth and clogging.
В iAVs, carefully graded sand performs several functions. Fine biochar could restrict drainage and aeration. Nutrient adsorption may provide buffering or temporarily immobilise nutrients. Alkalinity and soluble salts could disrupt nutrient availability. Greater water retention may affect the irrigation–drainage cycle, while additional microbial habitat does not necessarily improve nitrification, mineralisation or production.
The review cites Oyebode’s 2025 thesis comparing sand alone with biochar, compost or both under freshwater and brackish-water conditions. However, these findings do not establish improved performance in the original iAVs design.
The NCSU research remains the tested benchmark. Any claimed improvement requires replicated, controlled comparisons under the original operating conditions, measuring crop yield, fish performance, nutrient availability, water chemistry, drainage, oxygen and long-term hydraulic stability.
Until then, biochar’s benefits in iAVs remain unverified.
Works Cited
Baldoni, Nora, et al. “Biochar in Controlled Environment Agriculture.” Agronomy, vol. 16, no. 14, 2026, article 1335. https://doi.org/10.3390/agronomy16141335.
McMurtry, Mark R., et al. “Efficiency of Water Use of an Integrated Fish/Vegetable Co-Culture System.” Журнал Всемирного общества аквакультуры, vol. 28, no. 4, 1997, pp. 420–428. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1749-7345.1997.tb00290.x.
Oyebode, Gabriel. Evaluating the Performance of Broccoli in the Sandponics System Using Brackish Water with Biochar and Compost. Master’s thesis, American University in Cairo, 2025. https://fount.aucegypt.edu/etds/2467/.