Adicionando biochar à areia de veículos aéreos inoperantes (iAVs): o que a pesquisa mostra? Parte 1

Biochar is sometimes added to growing media in the belief that it improves water retention, nutrient availability and plant growth. But does adding it to the sand in an iAVs actually help, or could it interfere with the processes that make the original design work?

Review of Mine et al. (2006)

Mine et al. (2006) compared plain sand with sand amended with several materials, including 9% granular coconut-shell activated carbon by volume. Each treatment had four replicates.

The Japanese experiment used shallow 8 cm sand beds, commercial fertilisers and drip irrigation. It differed from the original NCSU iAVs design, which uses deeper sand beds, intermittent recirculation and fish-derived nutrients.

Key findings

Compared with plain sand, the activated-carbon treatment produced:

  • 46% less root dry mass: 23.3 g versus 43.0 g.
  • 20% less above-ground dry mass: 105 g versus 131 g.
  • Significantly fewer tomatoes: 14.6 versus 17.4 per plant.
  • Lower fruit sugar content and acidity, with significant reductions in the measured fruit trusses.
  • Significantly fewer fungi, although heterotrophic bacterial counts did not differ significantly.
  • Higher substrate pH, approximately 0.3–0.6 units above plain sand.

Total tomato yield was approximately 7% lower, although this difference was not statistically significant.

The amended sand also held approximately 13% more water at maximum water-holding capacity, but this did not improve overall production.

Implications for iAVs

Drainage and oxygenation

iAVs depends on repeated wetting and draining of graded sand. Increased water retention is beneficial only when adequate drainage and aeration are maintained.

Separate studies found that adding biochar to sand can substantially reduce saturated hydraulic conductivity (the rate at which water passes through saturated material). This raises concerns about altering the original iAVs filtration and drainage characteristics (Barnes et al., 2014; Brockhoff et al., 2010).

Nutrient availability

Mine et al. suspected that micronutrient deficiency, possibly boron, contributed to reduced growth.

Biochar can also change nutrient retention and release, with effects varying by material and nutrient type (Yao et al., 2012).

In iAVs, these changes could affect nutrients supplied through fish waste and recycled water.

Microbial activity

The significantly lower fungal populations warrant investigation, particularly because microorganisms contribute to organic matter decomposition in iAVs.

pH

Activated carbon increased substrate pH, potentially affecting nutrient availability and ammonia chemistry.

Whether ordinary biochar would produce similar changes in iAVs remains unknown. The original iAVs design specifies chemically inert sand; adding biochar introduces a potentially reactive material.

Conclusion

These findings provide scientific reasons for caution when considering biochar additions to iAVs.

The Japanese experiment demonstrated that greater water retention does not necessarily improve plant growth or production. Several measures of tomato performance declined following activated-carbon addition.

Although activated carbon and ordinary biochar differ in their properties, both can alter the physical and chemical characteristics of sand.

Claims that biochar improves iAVs remain unverified without replicated, controlled comparisons against the original NCSU design.

The scientific approach is to teach the researched iAVs method as established, while treating proposed modifications as hypotheses requiring experimental validation.


References

Barnes, Rebecca T., et al. “Biochar-Induced Changes in Soil Hydraulic Conductivity and Dissolved Nutrient Fluxes Constrained by Laboratory Experiments.” PLOS ONE, vol. 9, no. 9, 2014, article e108340. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0108340.

Brockhoff, Shane R., et al. “Physical and Mineral-Nutrition Properties of Sand-Based Turfgrass Root Zones Amended with Biochar.” Agronomy Journal, vol. 102, no. 6, 2010, pp. 1627–1631. https://doi.org/10.2134/agronj2010.0188.

Mine, Yoko, et al. “Effects of Substrate Materials Mixed with Sands on Substrate Properties and Tomato Fruit Production in Sandponics.” Horticultural Research (Japan), vol. 5, no. 4, 2006, pp. 381–388. https://doi.org/10.2503/hrj.5.381.

Yao, Ying, et al. “Effect of Biochar Amendment on Sorption and Leaching of Nitrate, Ammonium, and Phosphate in a Sandy Soil.” Chemosphere, vol. 89, no. 11, 2012, pp. 1467–1471. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.chemosphere.2012.06.002.