A South African aquaponics supplier claims that 18 months of scientific research proved sandponics inevitably fails. But where is the research? An examination of his published statements, academic involvement and commercial advertising reveals serious questions about the evidence consumers are being asked to trust.
On 10 December 2025, Martin Fick’s Home Grown Practical Aquaponics Facebook page published a warning titled The Sandponics HYPE!
The message was emphatic. Fick claimed his organisation had conducted an 18-month, university-level microbiology and biochemistry study involving a control and four experimental variants. According to the post, every variation failed, sand beds became anaerobic after approximately six months, and the medium eventually required complete replacement.
His verdict was unequivocal: sandponics fails “100% of the time” in the long run.
That is an extraordinary scientific claim, particularly from someone operating a business that sells competing aquaponics equipment, systems, training and consultancy.
Yet the original Facebook publication identifies no university, investigators, experimental dates, research report or dataset.
There are no results tables, measurements, statistical analyses or documented descriptions of the control and four variants. We are not told what sand was used, how it was graded, how the beds were constructed, what biological loading they received or how irrigation and drainage were managed.
These details are fundamental to evaluating any sand-based biological filtration experiment.
The audience is being asked to accept an absolute scientific verdict without being given the evidence needed to examine it.
The university research nobody can inspect
Fick has a genuine connection with academic research. In 2019, he co-authored a peer-reviewed paper on iron supplementation in aquaponics alongside researchers affiliated with Rhodes University.
A separate 2020 microbiology study examined bacterial communities at the Practical Aquaponics farm in Salem, South Africa.
That study provides an instructive comparison.
Its authors were identified, their affiliations disclosed, their methods explained and their findings published. They described the growing medium, experimental sampling, analytical procedures and microbial communities. The underlying sequencing data were deposited in a public research archive.
There is one particularly important detail: the growing medium was approximately 19 mm gravel, not sand.
The published study examined bacterial communities in gravel beds associated with a recirculating aquaponics system. It did not establish that sandponics fails after six months.
This raises an obvious question. If Fick’s organisation conducted another, much longer university-level experiment that allegedly proved an entire agricultural technology unsustainable, why has the December 2025 declaration supplied none of the corresponding documentation?
An unpublished experiment can certainly be legitimate. However, its scientific conclusions remain unverified until sufficient evidence is made available. That which can be said without evidence…… Extraordinary claims require……
Calling research university-level does not make its conclusions independently verifiable.
The science he dismisses already existed
Integrated Aqua-Vegeculture Systems (iAVs) were experimentally developed at North Carolina State University during the 1980s.
The system combines fish production with vegetable cultivation in intermittently irrigated sand beds, using microbial processes to treat and recycle aquaculture water.
In 1990, McMurtry, Nelson, Sanders and Hodges published Sand Culture of Vegetables Using Recirculated Aquacultural Effluents in Applied Agricultural Research.
That research demonstrated integrated fish and vegetable production in recirculating sand beds without additional fertiliser application. Further investigations appeared during the 1990s, including published work on tomato yields, nutrient dynamics, component ratios and water-use efficiency.
These studies establish a substantial experimental foundation that cannot reasonably be dismissed with an unsupported universal failure claim.
Also, sandponics is the incorrect name, and this nae has never been used in any of the research, so this failure to do a basic literature review and to use the correct name is a giant red flag, this is certainly below “univiersity level”.
Fick’s warning also contains real biological concerns presented as inevitable outcomes. Excessive organic loading, poor drainage, inappropriate particle sizes and accumulated biofilms can impair a sand bed. Oxygen depletion and anaerobic conditions are possible. But demonstrating that a badly configured sand bed can fail is very different from demonstrating that properly designed iAVs systems must fail.
His comparison with swimming-pool sand filters overlooks the different hydraulic conditions, biological functions and operating arrangements of intermittently irrigated, planted sand beds.
His explanation also associates methane production with facultative aerobic bacteria, although biological methane production is primarily associated with methanogenic archaea operating under anaerobic conditions. Methane itself is odourless; hydrogen sulfide produces the characteristic rotten-egg smell.
These are reasons to examine his microbiological explanation critically, rather than treating it as settled science.
Follow the commercial claims
The evidentiary concerns extend beyond sandponics.
On 12 March 2017, Fick published Aquaponics or Hydroponics? on the Practical Aquaponics website.
The article promoted his company’s approach as requiring less than 10% of the water used by unspecified alternatives, involving no synthetic or inorganic chemicals, and causing no negative environmental impact.
It also portrayed hydroponically grown produce as unhealthy because of its synthetic nutrient inputs, while characterising hydroponic nutrient solutions as normally discharged into the environment.
No controlled water-use comparison, food-safety analysis or environmental assessment was supplied to establish those sweeping conclusions. Recirculating hydroponic systems, which reuse nutrient solutions, were effectively disregarded.
The chemical-free marketing is particularly revealing when compared with the company’s other activities.
In 2019, Fick co-authored Iron Supplementation and Management in Aquaponic Systems: A Review, published in Aquaculture Reports.
The paper recommends synthetic iron chelates, including Fe-EDDHA and Fe-HBED, under particular aquaponic conditions. It also acknowledges limitations in the available evidence concerning supplementation effects.
Meanwhile, Practical Aquaponics advertises Fe-EDDHA iron chelate for sale. Its catalogue also lists products including potassium hydroxide, calcium hydroxide and magnesium sulphate.
There is nothing inherently improper about selling these substances. Some have legitimate applications in aquaponics.
The problem is the consistency of the message.
How does a business reconcile categorical advertising about using no synthetic or inorganic chemicals with its founder’s published advocacy of synthetic supplementation and its own sale of chemical amendments?
Selling these products does not prove that every customer uses them or that every company installation depends on them. It does, however, make the unqualified chemical-free sales language difficult to defend without a clear explanation of what the company actually means.
Consumers choosing systems specifically to avoid synthetic inputs deserve that explanation before purchasing.
Who benefits from the warning?
Practical Aquaponics is a commercial supplier. Its website promotes proprietary system designs, equipment, training, consumables and technical expertise.
Sandponics represents another approach to integrated fish and vegetable production, potentially competing for some of the same customers.
This creates an identifiable commercial interest in how alternative technologies are portrayed.
Fick’s December 2025 post goes beyond expressing technical reservations. It describes sandponics as a gimmick, warns that unsuspecting people could become victims, and presents his organisation as having scientifically established its inevitable failure.
Such language may discourage prospective buyers from investigating sandponics while reinforcing confidence in the author’s expertise and commercial alternatives.
That potential advantage is worth examining. It is not, by itself, proof that Fick knowingly published false information or deliberately targeted competitors.
He may genuinely believe his conclusions. His organisation may also possess valid but undisclosed experimental results. Poor system design, unsuitable sand or operational difficulties could explain failures in particular trials.
The appropriate way to resolve those possibilities is through evidence.
For a business that advertises scientifically tested and proven systems, the standard should be especially clear.
A warning to consumers
Anyone considering purchasing an aquaponics system, paying for specialist training or accepting a supplier’s claims about competing technologies should demand supporting information.
For the alleged sandponics experiment, that means the research institution, investigators, protocol, sand specifications, biological loading, hydraulic design, measurements, documented failures and complete results.
For commercial aquaponics products, consumers should request realistic operating costs, nutrient and chemical input requirements, independently substantiated performance figures and clarification of environmental and food-safety claims.
A product advertised as proven should come with evidence relevant to the conditions in which customers intend to operate it.
A claimed university-level experiment should be traceable and open to meaningful scrutiny.
And a business promising chemical-free production should clearly explain which chemical amendments its systems may require.
The unanswered question
Martin Fick’s public statements present an uncomfortable contrast.
In 2017, he promoted aquaponics with expansive claims about chemical-free production, environmental safety and water savings. In 2019, he co-authored scientific literature recommending synthetic iron supplementation. In 2020, identifiable academic collaborators published a microbiological investigation of gravel beds at his farm.
Then, in December 2025, his business announced that an 18-month university-level investigation had established the universal failure of sandponics — without disclosing the experiment’s identifying details or results.
The existing record establishes significant gaps in substantiation and inconsistencies in commercial messaging. It does not establish that the alleged study was fabricated, that deliberate deception occurred or that consumer-protection law was breached.
But consumers should not have to take scientific declarations on faith, particularly when those declarations come from a business selling alternative products.
Until the alleged 18-month study is available for independent examination, the claim that sandponics fails 100% of the time remains an unsupported public assertion, not an established scientific conclusion.
And when someone invokes science to warn customers away from a competing technology, asking to see that science is the most reasonable response.
Documentary review dated 22 October 2026. Based on the archived Facebook statement, Practical Aquaponics’ published commercial materials and the identified academic publications. No finding of intentional dishonesty or regulatory wrongdoing is asserted.
