Hanyoyin Haɗi na Al'adun Yashi ga Masu Bincike

Important: iAVs, sandponics, aquaponics, and sand-culture are all distinct, separate growing methods, they are not connected.

iAVs is the Integrated Aqua-Vegeculture System developed by Dr. Mark R. McMurtry. It is a distinct, specified agricultural methodology, not a generic name for commercial aquaponics. Its research findings cannot automatically be attributed to other aquaponics systems, nor can their failures be attributed to iAVs.

Sand Culture. Concurrent with the beginning of rockwool culture in Denmark in 1969, a type of open-system aggregate hydroponics, initially for desert applications and using pure sand as the growing medium, was under development by researchers at the University of Arizona (Jensen 1973). It was logical to investigate such potential. Because other types of growing media must be imported to desert regions and may require frequent renewal, they are more expensive than sand, a commodity usually available in abundance (Jensen & Malter, 1995).

The Arizona researchers designed and tested several types of sand-based hydroponic systems. The growth of tomatoes and other greenhouse crops in pure sand was compared with the growth in nine other mixtures (e.g. sand mixed in varying ratios with vermiculite, rice hulls, redwood bark, pine bark, perlite, peat moss, etc.). There were no significant differences in yield (Jensen and Collins 1985). Unlike many other growing media, which undergo physical breakdown during use, sand is a permanent medium. It does not require replacement every 1 or 2 years (Jensen & Malter, 1995).

Pure sand can be used in trough or trench culture. However, in desert locations, it is often more convenient and less expensive to cover the greenhouse floor with polyethylene film and a system of drainage pipes (PVC pipe 5 cm in diameter, cross cut one third through every 45 cm down the length of the pipe with cuts faced down) and then to backfill the area with sand to a depth of approximately 30 cm. If the sand bed is shallower, moisture conditions may not be uniform and plant roots may grow into the drain pipes. The areas to be used as planting beds may be level or slightly sloped. Supply manifolds for nutrient solution must be sited accordingly (Jensen & Malter, 1995).

Different types of desert and coastal sands with various physical and chemical properties were used successfully by the University of Arizona workers. The size distribution of sand particles is not critical, with the exception of very fine materials, such as mortar sand, which does not drain well and should be avoided. If calcareous sand is used, it is important to maintain a nutrient solution of neutral pH. Increased amounts of chelated iron must be applied to the plants. Sand growing beds should be fumigated annually because of possible introduction of soil borne diseases and nematodes (Jensen & Malter, 1995).

Irrigation practices are particularly critical during the high-radiation summer months, when irrigation may be necessary up to eight times per day. Proper irrigation is indicated by a small but continuous drainage, 4–7 percent of the application, from the entire growing area. Evaporation of water around small summer tomato transplants is often high, which can lead to a slight buildup of fertilizers in the planting beds. Extra nitrogen causes excessive vegetative growth, thus decreasing the number of fruits. This can be avoided by reducing the amount of nitrogen in the solution from the time of transplant until the appearance of the first blossoms. Drainage from the beds should be tested frequently, and the beds leached when drainage salts exceed 3000 ppm (Jensen & Malter, 1995).

The principal crops grown in sand culture systems are tomatoes and cucumbers, and yields of both crops have been high. Seedless cucumber production has exceeded 700 MT/ha (Jensen & Malter, 1995).

Greenhouse pepper plants grow in pure sand in a facility designed by the University of Arizona on Kharg Island, Iran. Plants are drip irrigated with nutrient solution.

Greenhouse eggplants are grown on beach sand along the Gulf of California in a cooperative research project of the University of Arizona and the University of Sonora, Hermosillo. Sonora, Mexico.

Source; Jensen, Merle H.; Malter, Alan J. Protected agriculture : a global review (English). World Bank technical paper ; no. WTP 253 Washington, D.C. : The World Bank. http://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/170171468765017779

1920* — E. S. Johnston — “Nutrient Requirement of the Potato Plant Grown in Sand Cultures Treated with ‘Type I’ Solutions.” Soil Science, vol. 10, pp. 389–408

1924* — E. S. Johnston — “Growth of Potato Plants in Sand Cultures Treated with the ‘Six Types’ of Nutrient Solutions.” Maryland Agricultural Experiment Station Bulletin 270.

1925* — E. S. Johnston — “Comparative Study of the ‘Six Types’ of Nutrient Solutions in Relation to the Growth of Potato Plants in Sand Cultures.” Soil Science 20.

1928* — F. G. Gregory — “The Differential Effect of the Ions of Three-Salt Solutions on the Growth of Potato Plants in Sand Culture.” Proceedings of the Royal Society B 102:311–327.

1934 — O. W. Davidson & J. W. Shive — “The Influence of the Hydrogen-Ion Concentration of the Culture Solution upon the Absorption and Assimilation of Nitrate and Ammonium Nitrogen by Peach Trees Grown in Sand Cultures.” Soil Science 37:357–382.

1937* — J. W. Shive & W. R. Robbins — “Methods of Growing Plants in Solution and Sand Cultures.” New Jersey Agricultural Experiment Station Bulletin.

1938 — A. A. Dunlap — “Growth of Cabbage Seedlings in Sand Culture, as Affected by Delayed Application of Nutrient Salts.” Plant Physiology 13:631–640.

1939 — R. M. Woodman — “Studies in the Nutrition of Vegetables: The Effects of Variation in the Nitrogen Supply on Lettuce … in Sand Culture.” Annals of Botany 3:649–656.

1939 — R. M. Woodman — “Studies in the Nutrition of Vegetables: Phosphate Deficiency and Yield Tests on Sand Cultures of May King Lettuce.” Journal of Agricultural Science 29:229–248.

1940* — V. G. Heller, R. H. Hageman & E. L. Hartman — “Sand Culture Studies of the Use of Saline and Alkaline Waters in Greenhouses.” Plant Physiology 15:727–733. https://doi.org/10.1104/pp.15.4.727

1943* — Hugh G. Gauch & Cecil H. Wadleigh — “A New Type of Intermittently-Irrigated Sand Culture Equipment.” Plant Physiology 18:543–547. https://doi.org/10.1104/pp.18.4.543

1943* — Moyer D. Thomas, Russel H. Hendricks, James O. Ivie & George R. Hill — “An Installation of Large Sand-Culture Beds Surmounted by Individual Air-Conditioned Greenhouses.” Plant Physiology 18:334–344.

1944 — F. Hicks & M. A. H. Tincker — “A Simple Method of Growing Carnations and Other Plants in Sand.” Journal of the Royal Horticultural Society 69:112–113.

1946* — W. G. Templeman — “The Automatic Surface Application of Nutrient Solution for the Sand Culture of Plants.” Chemistry & Industry. Includes intermittent/surface irrigation work with tomato. Chemistry & Industry, no. 38, pp. 348–349.

1950 — S. Pattanaik — “A Simple Sand Culture Equipment for Growing Rice Plants.” Current Science 19:321–322.

1960* — T. Osawa — “Studies on the Salt Tolerance of Vegetable Crops in Sand Culture. I. On Fruit Vegetables.” Journal of the Japanese Society for Horticultural Science 29:294–304.

1961* — T. Osawa — “Studies on the Salt Tolerance of Vegetable Crops in Sand Culture. III. On Root Vegetables.” Journal of the Japanese Society for Horticultural Science 30:161–166.

1961 — T. Osawa — “Studies on the Salt Tolerance of Vegetable Crops in Sand Culture. IV.” Journal of the Japanese Society for Horticultural Science 30:241–252.

1962 — T. Osawa — “Studies on the Sodium Chloride Injury of Vegetable Crops in Relation to the Form of Nitrogen in Sand Culture. I. On Some Fruit Vegetables.”

1962 — T. Osawa — “…II. On Some Leaf Vegetables and Root Vegetables.”

1963* — T. Osawa — “Studies on the Salt Tolerance of Vegetable Crops with Special Reference to Osmotic Effects and Specific Ion Effects.” Journal of the Japanese Society for Horticultural Science 32:211–223.

1963 — J. C. Cain — “Automatic Sub-Irrigation Equipment for Sand Culture.” Proceedings of the American Society for Horticultural Science 82:631–636.

1963 — H. S. Swan & D. Stewart — “An Automatic Sub-Irrigation Sand Culture Apparatus.” Forest Science 9:63–67.

1964 — Ralph Mitchell & Zvi Nevo. “Effect of Bacterial Polysaccharide Accumulation on Infiltration of Water Through Sand.” Applied Microbiology 12(3): 219–223.

1966* — B. C. Hanger — “A Continuous Irrigation System for Use in Sand Culture Experiments.” Australian Journal of Experimental Agriculture 6:331–333. Tomatoes were grown for months in washed river sand with recirculating nutrient solution.

1966 — Fukushima, Eiji, and Hiroji Kishimoto. Theory and Practice of Sand Cultivation. Fumin Association Publishing Department, 1966. National Diet Library digitised book. This is an important early reference, cited in both Japanese research and Sumitomo’s technical history.

1967 — W. J. Lovett et al. — “An Automatic Irrigation Sand Culture Technique.”

1968 — Albert B. Pincince & Jack E. McKee. “Oxygen Relationships in Intermittent Sand Filtration.” Journal of the Sanitary Engineering Division, ASCE 94(SA6): 1093–1119. It examines intermittent wetting of sand, oxygen depletion while wetted, and atmospheric oxygen re-entry after drainage.

1969* — R. K. Osborn & B. C. Hanger — “A Simple Automatic Irrigation System for Growing Plants in Sand Culture.” Australian Journal of Experimental Agriculture 9:367–368.

1969 — Konohomoto, Haruo, et al. “Studies on Irrigation of Fruit Vegetables (Tomato and Cucumber) in Sand Cultivation.” Shizuoka Agricultural Experiment Station Research Bulletin, no. 13, pp. 97–103. The citation is reproduced in Mine et al. (2006). A separate secondary source gives 1968, so the publication year requires checking against the original.

1970 — D. N. Maynard, A. V. Barker & H. F. Vernell — “A Semi-Automatic Sand Culture System for Greenhouse Plant Nutrition Research.” Agronomy Journal 62:304–306.

1970* — G. Jager, J. van der Boon & G. J. G. Rauw — sand-culture experiments with trickle irrigation. Netherlands Journal of Agricultural Science 18:158–167.

1970 — Merle H. Jensen & C. N. Hodges — “Plastics and Their Use in Vegetable Production in Desert Regions of the World.” Proceedings of the National Agricultural Plastics Conference. Relevant background to Jensen’s desert sand-culture programme.

1971* — Merle H. Jensen & M. A. Teran — “Use of Controlled Environment for Vegetable Production in Desert Regions of the World.” HortScience 6:33–36. Agecon Search

1971 — Merle H. Jensen — “The Use of Polyethylene Barriers Between Soil and Growing Medium in Greenhouse Vegetable Production.” Proceedings of the 10th National Agricultural Plastics Conference, pp. 144–149. Wiley Online Library

1971* — M. R. Fontes, J. O’Toole & Merle H. Jensen — “Vegetable Production under Plastic on the Desert Seacoast of Abu Dhabi.” Proceedings of the 10th National Agricultural Plastics Conference.

1972* — Merle H. Jensen & Hamdy M. Eisa — Controlled-Environment Vegetable Production: Results of Trials at Puerto Peñasco, Mexico, 1968–1970. Environmental Research Laboratory, University of Arizona, 118 pp. Agecon Search

1972 — E. B. Dumbroff & A. W. Cooper — “A Simplified Technique for Automatic Surface Irrigation of Plants in Sand Cultures.” Canadian Journal of Botany 50:383–385.

1973* — Merle H. Jensen & N. G. Hicks — “Exciting Future for Sand Culture.” American Vegetable Grower 21(11):33–34, 72–74. AnyFlip

1973 — Merle H. Jensen, Hamdy M. Eisa & M. Fontes — “The Pride of Abu Dhabi.” American Vegetable Grower 21(11):35, 68, 70. AnyFlip

1973* — M. R. Fontes — “Controlled-Environment Horticulture in the Arabian Desert at Abu Dhabi.” HortScience 8:13–16.

1973* — Masao Toyama — “Fundamental Research on the Suna Saibai (a Type of Sand Culture). I. Relationship between the Physical Composition of the Sand and its Total Porosity as well as Water Holding Capacity.” Journal of the Japanese Society for Horticultural Science 42:241–250. https://doi.org/10.2503/jjshs.42.241

1973* — Masao Toyama — “…II. Relationship between the Physical Composition of the Sand and its Evaporation.” Journal of the Japanese Society for Horticultural Science 42:251–258. https://doi.org/10.2503/jjshs.42.251

1973 — A. V. Delap & J. W. R. Aylott — “Automatic Sub-Irrigation Equipment for Sand Culture Experiments on Fruit Trees.” Horticultural Research 13:17–24.

1974* — Masao Toyama — “…IV. Relationship between the Physical Composition of Sand Media and the Growth Response of Cucumber Seedlings.” Journal of the Japanese Society for Horticultural Science 43:229–236. https://doi.org/10.2503/jjshs.43.229

1974 — Masao Toyama — “Fundamental Research on the Suna Saibai (a Type of Sand Culture). III. Nitrification in the Sand.” Journal of the Japanese Society for Horticultural Science 42:317–325. https://doi.org/10.2503/jjshs.42.317. Highly relevant as independent, earlier scientific evidence demonstrating effective microbial nitrification in sand. The study confirms biological principles also demonstrated in iAVs, but establishes no historical or developmental connection to the independently developed NCSU system.

1974 — C. S. Andrew — “Automatic Sub-Irrigation Sand Culture Technique for Comparative Studies in Plant Nutrition.” Laboratory Practice 23:20–21.

1974 — A. R. Mazur & T. D. Hughes — “Simple Method for Growth of Small Plants in Nutrient-Sand Culture.” Agronomy Journal 66:825–826.

1975* — Masao Toyama — “…V. Effects of Physical Composition of Sand Media, Air Temperature, and Irrigation on Growth Response of Cucumber Seedlings.” Journal of the Japanese Society for Horticultural Science 44:131–137. https://doi.org/10.2503/jjshs.44.131

1975* — Hamdy M. Eisa & Merle H. Jensen — “The Use of Calcareous Sand in Abu Dhabi as a Growing Medium in the Sand Culture System.” Acta Horticulturae 51. This is one of the most directly relevant Jensen publications. NCERA-101

1975 — Merle H. Jensen — “Arizona Research in Controlled Environment Agriculture.” Proceedings of the Tennessee Valley Greenhouse Vegetable Workshop, pp. 13–82. Wiley Online Library

1978* — P. C. Brookes — “Control of Evaporation and Surface-Accumulation of Nutrients in Sand-Culture Experiments with Oak Seedlings.” Journal of Applied Ecology 15:635–637.

1979* — B. A. Notton, E. F. Watson & E. J. Hewitt — “Effects of N-Serve Formulations on Nitrification and on Loss of Nitrate in Sand Culture Experiments.” Plant and Soil 51.

1980 — Suzuki, Akio, et al. “Report on Practical Application Trials of Sand Cultivation (6th Report).” Abstracts of the Japanese Society for Horticultural Science, Spring 1980, pp. 322–323. National Diet Library catalogue. A direct historical source on the development of Japanese sand cultivation

1980* — J. C. Ojala & W. M. Jarrell — “Hydroponic Sand Culture Systems for Mycorrhizal Research.” Plant and Soil 57:297–303.

1980* — Merle H. Jensen — “The Sand Culture System in Controlled Environment Agriculture.” Proceedings of the International Symposium on Controlled Environment Agriculture, University of Arizona. This publication is independently cited in subsequent soilless-culture literature. ResearchSpace

1982* — A. Luque — “Retention of Ions by Volcanit Sand Used in Hydroponic Cultures.” Acta Horticulturae 126. Particularly relevant because it examines ion retention/release and nitrification in sand used for hydroponic cropping.

1983* — G. S. Smith, C. M. Johnston & I. S. Cornforth — “Comparison of Nutrient Solutions for Growth of Plants in Sand Culture.” New Phytologist 94:537–548.

1984 — Suzuki, Akio. “Development of a Sand Cultivation System.” Iden (Heredity), vol. 38, no. 6, pp. 27–32. National Diet Library catalogue. Particularly relevant to the technical history of Japanese Sandponics.

1984 — Takeuchi, Yoshichika, et al. “Studies on the Practical Application of Sand-Cultivated Melons (Report 1).” Sand Dune Research, vol. 31, pp. 36–50. Examines melon growth, yield and three fertiliser treatments. Confirmed in the bibliography of Mine et al. (2006).

1984* — Yonemori, Shigeyasu. “A Modified Sand Culture of Tomatoes Using Coral Sands in Okinawa.” The Science Bulletin of the Faculty of Agriculture, University of the Ryukyus, no. 31, 1984, pp. 201–205. https://u-ryukyu.repo.nii.ac.jp/records/2003006. Long-term tomato production in highly calcareous local sand.

1985 – Hashimoto, Y. (1985). 植物栽培の新しいプロセス [New Processes in Plant Cultivation]. Keisoku to Seigyo (Journal of the Society of Instrument and Control Engineers), 24(10), 947–952. https://doi.org/10.11499/sicejl1962.24.947 Its most interesting finding for iAVs is that periodically supplying and draining nutrient solution produced higher photosynthetic activity than keeping roots continuously immersed. This provides independent experimental support for an important biological principle also incorporated into iAVs: alternating water supply with air exposure can benefit plant performance.

1985* — Merle H. Jensen & W. L. Collins — “Hydroponic Vegetable Production.” Horticultural Reviews 7. Major review covering aggregate and sand culture and preserving the bibliography of Jensen’s earlier sand work. Wiley Online Library

1987* — M. R. McMurtry, P. V. Nelson & D. C. Sanders — “Mineral Content and Yield of Bush Bean, Cucumber, and Tomato Cultivated in Sand and Irrigated with Recirculating Aquaculture Water.” HortScience 22(5, section 2):1138 / North Carolina Agricultural Research Service No. 11019. iAVs

1988 — Suzuki, Akio. Research on a Sand Cultivation System for Plants. University of Tokyo, doctoral dissertation, 1988. This may be the most significant missing historical document. Sumitomo cites it in its own technical history of Sandponics.

1988 — D. C. Sanders & M. R. McMurtry — “Fish Increase Greenhouse Profits.” American Vegetable Grower. Contemporary description of the NCSU sand-bed system.

1988* — D. O. Huett & E. B. Dettmann — “Effect of Nitrogen on Growth, Fruit Quality and Nutrient Uptake of Tomatoes Grown in Sand Culture.” Australian Journal of Experimental Agriculture 28:391–400.

1989* — A. Ibrahim, A. El-Gindy, A. Abou Hadid & A. Abdel Ghafar — “Recirculated Sand Culture for Tomato Under Protected Cultivation.” Egyptian Journal of Horticulture 16:181–198.

1990* — M. R. McMurtry, P. V. Nelson, D. C. Sanders & L. Hodges — “Al'adun Kayan Lambun Yashi Ta Amfani da Ruwan Ruwa Mai Sauƙi.” Binciken Noma Mai Amfani 5(4):280–284. Bush bean, cucumber and tomato were grown in deep sand beds with intermittent surface irrigation and complete water recirculation. iAVs

1990* — M. R. McMurtry & D. C. Sanders — “Aikin Tsarin Noma da Kifin da Aka Haɗaka Kamar yadda Rabon Kayan Aiki Ya Shafi.” HortScience 25(9):1151. Tomato and cucumber were grown in sand biofilters irrigated eight times daily. DOI 10.21273/HORTSCI.25.9.1151f. ResearchGate

1990* — M. R. McMurtry, D. C. Sanders, P. V. Nelson & R. G. Hodson — “Nutrient Dynamics in an Integrated Recirculatory Aquaculture-Vegetable Production System.” Proceedings of the XXIII International Horticultural Congress, Florence. iAVs

1990 — J. Lynch, E. Epstein, A. Läuchli & G. I. Weight — “An Automated Greenhouse Sand Culture System Suitable for Studies of P Nutrition.” Plant, Cell & Environment 13:547–554.

1992* — D. O. Huett & E. White — “Determination of Critical Nitrogen Concentrations of Potato (Solanum tuberosum L. cv. Sebago) Grown in Sand Culture.” Australian Journal of Experimental Agriculture 32:765–772.

1993* — M. R. McMurtry, D. C. Sanders, P. V. Nelson & A. Nash — “Mineral Nutrient Concentration and Uptake by Tomato Irrigated with Recirculating Aquaculture Water as Influenced by Quantity of Fish Waste Products Supplied.” Mujallar Abinci Mai Gina Jiki na Shuke-shuke 16:407–419. iAVs

1993* — M. R. McMurtry, D. C. Sanders, R. P. Patterson & A. Nash — “Yawan Tumatir da aka yi ban ruwa da shi tare da sake zagayawa a cikin ruwan ruwa.” Mujallar Noma ta Samar da Abinci 6:428–432. iAVs

1993 — Suzuki, Kazuhiro. “Nutrient and Water Management in a Strawberry Sand-Cultivation System Using a 7 cm Deep Sand Bed.” Japanese Journal of Soil Science and Plant Nutrition, vol. 64, no. 6, pp. 699–703. Free article. Useful for comparing shallow sand-bed designs and water management

1993 — H. Z. Zaiter & B. Mahfouz — “Salinity Effect on Root and Shoot Characteristics of Common and Tepary Beans Evaluated under Hydroponic Solution and Sand Culture.” Mujallar Abinci Mai Gina Jiki na Shuke-shuke 16:1569–1592.

1993 — Yu, Jing Quan, Kwang Seek Lee and Yoshihisa Matsui. “Effect of the Addition of Activated Charcoal to the Nutrient Solution on the Growth of Tomato in Hydroponic Culture.” Soil Science and Plant Nutrition, vol. 39, no. 1, pp. 13–22. Full article. Activated carbon improved tomato growth when added to the circulating nutrient solution. This provides a useful contrast with Mine et al. (2006), who incorporated activated carbon directly into sand and observed some adverse effects

1994 — Aaron L. Mills, Janet S. Herman, George M. Hornberger & Todd H. DeJesús. “Effect of Solution Ionic Strength and Iron Coatings on Mineral Grains on the Sorption of Bacterial Cells to Quartz Sand.” Applied and Environmental Microbiology 60(9):3300–3306.

1994 — I. A. Ali, U. Kafkafi, Y. Sugimoto & S. Inanaga — “Response of Sand-Grown Tomato Supplied with Varying Ratios of Nitrate/Ammonium to Constant and Variable Root Temperatures.” Mujallar Abinci Mai Gina Jiki na Shuke-shuke 17:2001–2024.

1994 — L. Mancini & G. Scarascia Mugnozza — “Yield and Quality of Chinese Cabbage Grown on Sand Culture and NFT System.” Acta Horticulturae 361:578–582.

1994 — F. Moulin, P. Lemanceau & C. Alabouvette — “Pathogenicity of Pythium Species on Cucumber in Peat-Sand, Rockwool and Hydroponics.” Relevant supporting evidence on disease ecology in sand-containing soilless media.

1995 — James M. Sperry & J. Jeffrey Peirce. “A Model for Estimating the Hydraulic Conductivity of Granular Material Based on Grain Shape, Grain Size, and Porosity.” Groundwater 33(6): 892–898. Direct experiments on sand showed particle size was the largest single predictor of hydraulic conductivity, while shape, porosity and their interactions also mattered.

1997 — Haruyuki Fujimaki, Nobuo Toride, Tahei Yamamoto & Mitsuhiro Inoue. “Solute Transport during Evaporation in a Sand Column with a Shallow Water Table.” Transactions of the Japanese Society of Irrigation, Drainage and Reclamation Engineering 1997(190):523–532.

1997* — J. Muro, V. Díaz, J. L. Goñi & C. Lamsfus — “Comparison of Hydroponic Culture and Culture in a Peat/Sand Mixture and the Influence of Nutrient Solution and Plant Density on Seed Potato Yields.” Potato Research 40:431–438. Not pure sand, but directly relevant to potato tuber production in soilless sand-containing media.

1997* — M. R. McMurtry, R. G. Hodson, D. C. Sanders & J. D. Cure — “Tasirin Yawan Tankin Biofilter/Al'adu akan Yawan Amfanin Tsarin Kifi/Kayan Lambu Mai Juyawa.” Mujallar Kifin da Aka Yi Amfani da shi 7(4):33–51. iAVs

1997* — M. R. McMurtry, D. C. Sanders, J. D. Cure, R. G. Hodson, B. C. Haning & P. C. St. Amand — “Ingancin Amfani da Ruwa na Tsarin Haɗaɗɗen Kifi/Kayan Lambu.” Mujallar Ƙungiyar Al'adun Kifi ta Duniya 28:420–428. Wiley Online Library

1999 — C. Croser, A. G. Bengough & J. Pritchard. “The Effect of Mechanical Impedance on Root Growth in Pea (Pisum sativum). I. Rates of Cell Flux, Mitosis, and Strain during Recovery.” Physiologia Plantarum 107:277–286.

2001 – Al-Ghawas, S. A., and A. K. Al-Mazidi. “Influence of fertigation frequency on the yield of some vegetables cultivated in sand culture.” International Symposium on Growing Media and Hydroponics 644. 2001.

2001 — Carlos A. Arias, Massimo Del Bubba & Hans Brix. “Phosphorus Removal by Sands for Use as Media in Subsurface Flow Constructed Reed Beds.” Water Research 35(5): 1159–1168. Thirteen different sands were compared. P retention varied substantially with sand chemistry; Ca, Fe and Al were particularly important.

2003* — M. G. Ahmed et al. — “Evaluation of Nutrient Film Technique and Sand Culture for Year-Round Production of Tomato … in Tropical Asia.” Asian Journal of Plant Sciences 2:420–424.

2003 — Massimo Del Bubba, Carlos A. Arias & Hans Brix. “Phosphorus Adsorption Maximum of Sands for Use as Media in Subsurface Flow Constructed Reed Beds as Measured by the Langmuir Isotherm.” Water Research 37(14): 3390–3400.

2004 — 2004 — S. A. Al-Ghawas & A. K. Al-Mazidi — “Influence of Fertigation Frequency on the Yield of Some Vegetables Cultivated in Sand Culture.” Acta Horticulturae 644:485–492. https://doi.org/10.17660/ActaHortic.2004.644.65. A two-year greenhouse study in Kuwait comparing fertiliser application frequencies for tomatoes, chillies and eggplants grown in sand. Twice-weekly fertilisation generally maintained high yields with less fertiliser than more frequent applications. The study used chemical fertilisers and a different cultivation method. Its findings may have some relevance to iAVs but cannot be directly applied to it.

2006 – Mine, Yoko, et al. “Effects of Substrate Materials Mixed with Sands on Substrate Properties and Tomato Fruit Production in Sandponics.” Horticultural Research (Japan), vol. 5, no. 4, 2006, pp. 381–388. https://doi.org/10.2503/hrj.5.381. A controlled, four-replicate tomato experiment comparing unamended sand with several substrate amendments. Adding 9% activated carbon reduced root biomass and fruit sugar content without significantly improving total fruit yield. This research used shallow 8 cm sand beds, drip irrigation and manufactured fertilisers. It did not investigate fish waste, biological filtration, intermittent flooding and drainage, or the integrated processes of iAVs. Consequently, the results cannot establish whether any of these amendments would improve or worsen the original NCSU system. They do, however, identify credible concerns worth investigating. The authors explain that the Japanese sandponics cultivation system was developed commercially around 1980, following earlier Japanese sand-culture research. This was a separate Japanese sand-culture development, not evidence of a developmental relationship with McMurtry’s independently developed iAVs. The shared English terminology should not be mistaken for technological equivalence Its strongest contribution to iAVs education is the distinction between improving an isolated property and demonstrating an improvement in overall system performance.

2008 — Saeed Torkzaban, Shiva S. Tazehkand, Sharon L. Walker & Scott A. Bradford. “Transport and Fate of Bacteria in Porous Media: Coupled Effects of Chemical Conditions and Pore Space Geometry.” Water Resources Research 44:W04403. Experiments in ultrapure quartz sand demonstrate that microbial retention depends jointly on water chemistry and the geometry of the pore network.

2009 — Masaru Sakai, Nobuo Toride & Jiří Šimůnek. “Water and Vapor Movement with Condensation and Evaporation in a Sandy Column.” Soil Science Society of America Journal 73:707–717. Separates liquid capillary flow, film flow and vapour movement in dry/wetting sand.

2009 — L. Rolland, P. Molle, A. Liénard, F. Bouteldja & A. Grasmick. “Influence of the Physical and Mechanical Characteristics of Sands on the Hydraulic and Biological Behaviors of Sand Filters.” Desalination 248(1–3): 998–1007. Particle-size distribution, compaction, moisture, infiltration, drainage, oxygen in pore space, nitrogen transformations, biological activity and clogging were measured together

2012 – Yao, Ying, et al. “Effect of biochar amendment on sorption and leaching of nitrate, ammonium, and phosphate in a sandy soil.” Chemosphere 89.11 (2012): 1467-1471.

2012* — Darvishi, Postini, Ahmadi, Tavakkol Afshari and Shaterian — “Possibility of Replacing Current Commercial Potato Mini-Tuber Production System by Hydroponic Sand Culture.” It appears in the Iranian Journal of Field Crop Science (University of Tehran)

2012 — A. Petitjean, N. Forquet, A. Wanko, J. Laurent, P. Molle, R. Mosé & A. Sadowski. “Modelling Aerobic Biodegradation in Vertical Flow Sand Filters: Impact of Operational Considerations on Oxygen Transfer and Bacterial Activity.” Water Research 46(7): 2270–2280.

2012 – Miyauchi, Yosuke, et al. “Soybean cultivation on desert sand using drip irrigation with mulch.” Plant Production Science 15.4 (2012): 310-316. The strongest inference is that a well-aerated sand bed can support productive legume cultivation and active symbiotic nitrogen fixation. That is consistent with the biological environment iAVs seeks to maintain through intermittent irrigation and drainage. However, the experiment used drip irrigation, desert sand, rhizobial inoculation and foliar nitrogen applications. It did not use fish effluent, recirculation or iAVs furrow-and-ridge beds. Its yield, nitrogen-fixation and irrigation figures therefore cannot be directly transferred to iAVs.

2014 — Carson O. Lee, Rasmus Boe-Hansen, Sanin Musovic, Barth F. Smets, Hans-Jørgen Albrechtsen & Philip J. Binning. “Effects of Dynamic Operating Conditions on Nitrification in Biological Rapid Sand Filters for Drinking Water Treatment.” Water Research 64: 226–236. Shows active nitrification in sand, its relationship with ammonium loading, flow and depth, and strong concentration of biological activity near the top of the sand bed.

2014 – Barnes, Rebecca T., et al. “Biochar-induced changes in soil hydraulic conductivity and dissolved nutrient fluxes constrained by laboratory experiments.” PloS one 9.9 (2014): e108340.

2015* — B. Darvishi et al. — “The Effect of Plantlets Density and Growth Media Composition on Potato Mini-Tuber Production in Hydroponic Sand Culture.” Compared sand media including different particle-size compositions.

2015* — B. Darvishi et al. — “Effect of Nutritional Treatments on Physiological Characteristics and Tuberization of Potato Plants under Hydroponic Sand Culture.” Mujallar Abinci Mai Gina Jiki na Shuke-shuke 38:2096–2111.

2015* — M. Baba & N. Ikeguchi — “Industrial Cultivation Using the Latest Sandponics System.” SEI Technical Review 80:104–108. Documents the Japanese commercial sand-culture lineage originating in the 1970s.

2015 — Sarah-Jane Haig, Christopher Quince, Robert L. Davies, Caetano C. Dorea & Gavin Collins. “The Relationship between Microbial Community Evenness and Function in Slow Sand Filters.” mBio 6(5):e00729-15.

2015 – Grishkan, Isabella, Rong Liang Jia, and Xin Rong Li. “Influence of sand burial on cultivable micro-fungi inhabiting biological soil crusts.” Pedobiologia 58.2-3 (2015): 89-96. This is a useful supporting reference for explaining the biological development of sand into a soil-like growing environment. It reinforces the importance of microorganisms, organic enrichment and habitat conditions, but provides no direct evidence about iAVs nutrient-processing efficiency.

2016 — Ali Firat Cabalar & Nurullah Akbulut. “Evaluation of Actual and Estimated Hydraulic Conductivity of Sands with Different Gradation and Shape.” SpringerPlus 5:820. Particularly useful for comparing natural rounded sand with crushed/angular sand across numerous particle-size fractions. Shape and grading significantly changed hydraulic conductivity.

2016 — Alain Petitjean, Nicolas Forquet & Catherine Boutin. “Oxygen Profile and Clogging in Vertical Flow Sand Filters for On-Site Wastewater Treatment.” Journal of Environmental Management 170:15–20.

2016 — Alejandro Palomo, S. Jane Fowler, Arda Gülay, Simon Rasmussen, Thomas Sicheritz-Pontén & Barth F. Smets. “Metagenomic Analysis of Rapid Gravity Sand Filter Microbial Communities Suggests Novel Physiology of Nitrospira spp.” The ISME Journal 10(11): 2569–2581. Metagenomics showed extensive microbial metabolism in sand, including genes covering much of the nitrogen cycle and strong nitrification capacity

2016* — Falah Hasan Issa — “Propagation of Potato Seed Tubers Using Nutrient Solution in Hydroponic and Sand Culture.” International Journal of Multidisciplinary and Current Research 4:1104–1106.

2016* — J. Lipiec, A. Siczek, A. Sochan & A. Bieganowski — “Effect of Sand Grain Shape on Root and Shoot Growth of Wheat Seedlings.” Geoderma 265:1–5. Particularly relevant to claims about angular versus rounded sand particles.

2017* — S. Kanazawa et al. — “High Quality Agricultural Production Support System by Smart Sand Cultivation Device ‘New Sandponics’.” SEI Technical Review.

2017 — Karolina Tatari, Sanin Musovic, Arda Gülay, Arnaud Dechesne, Hans-Jørgen Albrechtsen & Barth F. Smets. “Density and Distribution of Nitrifying Guilds in Rapid Sand Filters for Drinking Water Production: Dominance of Nitrospira spp.” Water Research 127: 239–248. Found roughly 10⁹–10¹⁰ bacterial cells per gram of filter material and substantial populations of nitrifiers, including Nitrospira.

2017* — F. X. Prenafeta-Boldú, I. Trillas, F. Viñas et al. — “Effectiveness of a Full-Scale Horizontal Slow Sand Filter for Controlling Phytopathogens in Recirculating Hydroponics: From Microbial Isolation to Full Microbiome Assessment.” Science of the Total Environment 599–600:780–788. Not a crop-medium experiment itself, but highly relevant evidence that working sand beds support complex, active microbial communities.

2017 — Robert Hird & Malcolm D. Bolton. “Clarification of Capillary Rise in Dry Sand.” Engineering Geology 230:77–83. Shows water can move substantially higher into unsaturated sand than simple capillary-tube calculations predict, including under strong surface evaporation.

2018* — P. Makokha et al. — “Optimization of Nutrient Media for Sweetpotato (Ipomoea batatas L.) Vine Multiplication in Sandponics.” Gates Open Research 2:59.

2018 — H. Misu, M. Mori, S. Okumura, S. Kanazawa, N. Ikeguchi & R. Nakai — “High-Quality Tomato Seedling Production System Using Artificial Light.” SEI Technical Review 86:119–124. Part of the Japanese New Sandponics programme.

2019 — Mahmoud Fakih, Jean-Yves Delenne, Farhang Radjai & Thierry Fourcaud. “Root Growth and Force Chains in a Granular Soil.” Physical Review E 99:042903.

2019 — Jayde A. Aufrecht, Jason D. Fowlkes, Amber N. Bible, Jennifer Morrell-Falvey, Mitchel J. Doktycz & Scott T. Retterer. “Pore-Scale Hydrodynamics Influence the Spatial Evolution of Bacterial Biofilms in a Microfluidic Porous Network.” PLOS ONE 14(6):e0218316.

2019/2020* — P. Makokha et al. — “Comparative Analysis for Producing Sweetpotato Pre-Basic Seed Using Sandponics and Conventional Systems.” Journal of Crop Improvement 34:84–102.

2020* — B. W. Wanjala et al. — “Improving Rapid Multiplication of Sweetpotato (Ipomoea batatas L.) Pre-Basic Seed Using Sandponics Technology in East Africa.” Experimental Agriculture 56:347–354.

2020* — J. K. Ayusa, J. B. Mukundi & A. O. Adimo — “Comparative Growth and Dry Matter Accumulation in Selected Tree Species in Response to Quarry Dust Media Amendments.” Journal of Horticulture and Forestry 12:122–129. Relevant specifically to the agricultural use of mechanically crushed quarry material.

2020 — M. S. Abu-Shahba, M. M. Mansour, H. I. Mohamed & M. R. Sofy — “Comparative Cultivation and Biochemical Analysis of Iceberg Lettuce Grown in Sand Soil and Hydroponics With or Without Microbubbles and Macrobubbles.” Journal of Soil Science and Plant Nutrition. DOI is 10.1007/s42729-020-00368-x.

2021 – Babakhani, S., et al. “Non‐sterile corn steep liquor a novel, cost effective and powerful culture media for Sporosarcina pasteurii cultivation for sand improvement.” Journal of Applied Microbiology 130.4 (2021): 1232-1244. This paper provides an additional scientific reason for iAVs to avoid calcium carbonate-containing sand, beyond the established risks of elevated pH, nutrient unavailability and increased ammonia toxicity. The additional concern is microbially induced calcium carbonate precipitation (MICP), which can physically cement sand grains together.

2021 — Elnaz Rezaei, Kamran Zeinalzadeh & Behzad Ghanbarian. “Experimental Study of Hydraulic Properties in Grain Packs: Effects of Particle Shape and Size Distribution.” Journal of Contaminant Hydrology 243:103918. Compared angular natural sand with spherical grains and directly measured moisture-characteristic curves and saturated hydraulic conductivity across different particle-size distributions.

2022* — H. Sewilam, F. Kimera, P. Nasr & M. Dawood — “A Sandponics Comparative Study Investigating Different Sand Media Based Integrated Aqua Vegeculture Systems Using Desalinated Water.” Scientific Reports 12:11093.

2023* — F. Kimera, M. Mugwanya, M. Dawood & H. Sewilam — “Growth Response of Kale and Nile Tilapia under Saline Aqua-Sandponics-Vegeculture System.” Scientific Reports 13:2427.

2024* — W. Jiang, J. Liu, Z. Gong, Y. Gao, Z. Li & Z. Tan — “Slightly Saline Water Improved Physiology, Growth, and Yield of Tomato Plants in Yellow Sand Substrate.” Noma 14:2315.

2024* — C. S. Nair et al. — “Sandponics: A Sustainable Agriculture Solution for Food Security and Resource Efficiency in Arid Regions.” Journal of Sustainable Agriculture and Environment 3:e70033. Important as a modern review assembling part of the historical sand-culture literature.

2024 — Salman & Abd-Alwahab — “Exploring the Physiological Traits of Eggplant (Solanum melongena L.) Cultivated in a Sandponics Growing System.” Journal of Global Innovations in Agricultural Sciences 12:522–528. https://doi.org/10.22194/JGIAS/24.1268

2025 — Oyebode, Gabriel. Evaluating the Performance of Broccoli (Brassica oleracea var. italica) in the Sandponics System Using Brackish Water with Biochar and Compost. American University in Cairo, master’s thesis, 2025. Directly examines sand, biochar, compost and their combinations.

2025 – Taylor, B. P. (2025). Addressing the conflation of sandponics and the Integrated Aqua-Vegeculture System (IAVS) in recent literature [pre-print]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.22946472

2025 – Taylor, B. (2025). The conflation of iAVs and sandponics: A commentary on Sewilam et al., (2022) [pre-print]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.22946542

2025* — W. Jiang et al. — “Optimal Irrigation Water Salinity Enhances Tomato Yield in Sand Culture by Regulating Substrate Salinity.” Agricultural Water Management 317:109632.

2025* — R. Subramanian et al. — “Integrating Desert Sand Utilization in Saltwater Aqua-Vegeculture Production: Performance Evaluation of Yield and Biochemical Composition.” Animals 15:1246.

2025 — Lukhwareni, Refilwe, et al. “The Assessment of Oreochromis mossambicus Muscle Tissue and the Yield Performance of Solanum tuberosum in a Small-Scale Sandponics System.” Environmental Science and Pollution Research, vol. 32, pp. 13847–13861. Relevant to fish-and-potato production using sand. Note that the experimental control omitted potatoes; it was not a comparison against the original NCSU design. DOI 10.1007/s11356-025-36495-0 (published 14 May 2025).

2026 — Ibrahim, Eman Khalil, Suaad K. Abd Al-Wahab and Nagham Saddon Ibrahim. “Changes in Selected Chemical Properties of Karbala and Jalawla Sands during Cultivation under a Sandponics System.” Dijlah Journal of Agricultural Sciences, vol. 5, no. 4, pp. 28–35. Measures changes in sand pH, electrical conductivity, mineral nitrogen and extractable silica. Its authors acknowledge the absence of an untreated control.