Murray Hallam et les allégations de mort des poissons à cause de la silice

An archival record of Murray Hallam’s experiments with the Integrated Aqua-Vegeculture System, his subsequent claims about silica-related fish mortality, the scientific and historical material surrounding those claims, and their circulation within the aquaponics industry, 2019–2026.

The origins of the controversy

Murray Hallam, founder of Practical Aquaponics Australia, operated an experimental ntegrated Aqua-Vegeculture System (iAVs).

Between 2019 and 2021, Hallam publicly discussed his experiments, acknowledged McMurtry’s original research and reported successful results. He described stable water chemistry, productive crops, healthy fish, low electricity requirements and the absence of routine mineral supplementation. In August 2022, Hallam announced that he had shut down the experiment. He attributed declining production to a suspected problem involving silica nanoparticles released from the sand through microbial activity.

In January 2025, he gave a more definite explanation, claiming that fish deaths beginning approximately 18 months into the experiment resulted from a condition he called silicosis. He further claimed that bacteria and fungi had broken down the sand, releasing silica into the water.

Hallam also referred to similar incidents at trout farms and a separate system in Canada. He criticised the duration of McMurtry’s original research, suggesting that the earlier experiments had been too short to reveal the problem.

The allegation subsequently circulated beyond Hallam’s own statements. In January 2026, Stephen Raisner repeated the explanation on the Aquaponics Association forum, while an account identified in the archive as belonging to Stephen Raisner repeated related claims on Facebook, including references to silica overdosing and food safety.

Hallam’s early knowledge of McMurtry’s research

Hallam had known about iAVs for many years before constructing his experimental system.

During a November 2019 appearance on Growing With Fishes, hosted by Stephen Raisner through Potent Ponics, Hallam explained that he had obtained McMurtry’s research papers approximately 12–13 years earlier. He was particularly interested in the findings concerning nutrient recovery from fish waste and the possibility of growing demanding crops without the mineral supplementation commonly required in conventional aquaponics.

Hallam described the sand medium as potentially superior to conventional gravel media in supporting biological processing and supplying plant nutrients. He also discussed McMurtry’s original humanitarian objectives: developing a low-energy, relatively inexpensive food-production system using accessible materials, including locally available sand.

The original research aimed to make integrated fish and vegetable cultivation accessible in regions where electricity, commercial fertilisers and expensive equipment were limited. Hallam’s experimental work was presented as an attempt to investigate and demonstrate those earlier findings.

Source: Growing With Fishes Podcast 179, Murray Hallam of Practical Aquaponics, 29 November 2019

The 2019 experimental installation

In early recordings of his iAVs, Hallam described the system operating for approximately four to five months.

He explained that the experiment was based on McMurtry’s work and showed crops growing in the sand beds, including beans, tomatoes and leafy vegetables. The installation had undergone modifications, including the addition of a larger, deeper fish tank. Hallam reported approximately 150 immature jade perch in the system at that stage.

He described harvesting tomatoes, establishing replacement crops and producing leafy vegetables that were supplied to charity.

Hallam also reported preliminary laboratory testing of water and plant tissues. The initial tests detected the nutrients examined, although some results were below expected concentrations. He attributed this partly to the system’s early developmental stage.

Further monthly testing was planned over approximately six to nine months, covering different growing conditions. Hallam stated that results would eventually be published and incorporated into his Aquaponics Design Course.

The experimental system was therefore publicly presented as an ongoing investigation into the performance of McMurtry’s technology.

Contemporary recordings include Murray’s iAV Sand Aquaponics System and the Practical Aquaponics Greenhouse Tour.

February 2021: Hallam publicly endorses the technology

On 9 February 2021, Practical Aquaponics published Hallam’s newsletter article, iAVS – Sand Ponics – Sand Gardening. Hallam wrote that he had been experimenting with the technology for approximately two years.

He reported:

We have systems operating very successfully

He also wrote:

I am now convinced that we ought to start adopting this technology where appropriate.

Hallam explicitly credited McMurtry with the original invention, describing the technology as:

certainly not my invention.

He explained that Bevan Suits, an acquaintance in the United States, had supplied him with McMurtry’s papers approximately ten years earlier. Hallam identified the absence of mineral supplementation as the principal feature that had attracted his interest. He contrasted this with conventional aquaponics, where additional nutrients are frequently required to sustain crops. He also described substantial electricity savings from intermittent irrigation. His sand beds were being irrigated for approximately 12 minutes every 90 minutes, making the system potentially suitable for solar-powered operation.

Hallam acknowledged ammonia accumulation between pumping cycles as a possible difficulty and stated that he had developed a method of addressing it. The same newsletter announced that the experimental sand beds would be demonstrated at his forthcoming Aquaponics Master Class, beginning on 1 March 2021. The technology was thus presented both as a promising experimental development and as a subject of Hallam’s commercial aquaponics education.

Primary source: Practical Aquaponics newsletter, 9 February 2021

The 22-month report: Stable pH, productive crops and healthy fish

A recorded discussion between Hallam and Stephen Raisner provides further details of the experimental system after approximately 22 months of operation.

Hallam described his iAVs with approximately 35 m² of growing area and 125 mature jade perch, each weighing roughly two pounds. This represents approximately 113 kg of fish biomass. He explained that the system used relatively coarse sand, intermittent flooding and drainage, and a pumping schedule restricted to daylight hours. Hallam stated that the system was producing excellent tomatoes. He also reported that routine mineral supplementation was unnecessary after the initial establishment period, during which compost tea had been added. His description of water chemistry was particularly significant. He reported that pH had settled around 6.4 without adjustment and that the stability predicted by McMurtry’s earlier research was being observed in his own installation.

Hallam described the fish as healthy and the system as requiring very little maintenance. He discussed tomato production as a demanding test of aquaponic nutrient availability and described the sand-based method as a potentially important direction for future aquaponics development.

Another Facebook comment, preserved in the evidence archive, records Hallam replying to John D. Silva Jr that he had been operating sand beds for 22 months and was confident in their construction and benefits. The archived comment and recorded interview document Hallam’s positive assessment at this stage of the experiment.

Source: Murray Hallam talks about iAVs, archived video transcript

August 2022: The shutdown and silica nanoparticle allegation

On 12 August 2022, Hallam responded to a question about his iAVs installation by announcing that it had been shut down. He described declining production after approximately two and a half years of operation. Hallam proposed that silica nanoparticles, referred to as SiNPs, had accumulated in the system as microorganisms gradually broke down the sand at a microscopic scale.

He identified this suspected process as a possible cause of the deterioration. Hallam also referred to several recorded cases at trout farms using sand filtration, claiming that comparable problems had occurred in those installations.

His statement included the admission:

We are yet to get lab tests done

He also acknowledged that the full nature of the problem had not been established. The August statement is the earliest dated account in the compiled record directly attributing the experimental failure to suspected silica nanoparticles released through biological activity in the sand.

The original Facebook post is preserved at:

Practical Aquaponics Facebook post, 12 August 2022

Its wording was subsequently reproduced in the iAVs documentary article published in February 2025.

January 2025: Fish deaths attributed to silicosis

On 25 January 2025, Hallam was asked about an iAVs eBook he had previously discussed producing.

He replied that he would not be publishing it because his experimental results had been unsatisfactory.

Hallam described a two-year trial, with plant health beginning to decline after approximately 12–15 months and fish mortality beginning around 18 months.

He then stated:

After several months, we discovered the problem of Silicosis.

Hallam explained that bacterial and fungal activity had broken down the sand microscopically, releasing silica into the system water and causing fish deaths.

He referred to a Canadian installation with which he had been cooperating, stating that it had experienced similar problems and that the operators had jointly identified the underlying issue.

Hallam also criticised the duration of McMurtry’s original experiments. He claimed that McMurtry had operated systems for only approximately six months before publishing successful results and suggested that longer operation was necessary to reveal problems.

His account also addressed water chemistry. Contrary to his earlier statement that pH had stabilised around 6.4, Hallam now reported that his experiment had not demonstrated the pH stability described in McMurtry’s papers.

A participant in the discussion asked whether silicosis had been found during a fish autopsy.

Hallam’s recorded response expressed surprise at the finding and again referred to the Canadian installation. He reiterated that the two operators had identified the problem and that he could not see a way around it because sand consists principally of silica.

The January 2025 exchange is preserved in:

Debunking Murray Hallam: Science vs. Misinformation, published 27 February 2025

The changing chronology of the experiment

The archive preserves several different descriptions of the experiment’s duration, performance and eventual deterioration. In February 2021, Hallam described successful operation over approximately 22 months. In the recorded 22-month discussion, he reported productive tomato crops, stable pH, healthy fish and successful operation without continuing mineral supplementation.

In August 2022, he announced that the experiment had been shut down after approximately two and a half years because production had declined. In January 2025, he placed the beginning of plant deterioration at approximately 12–15 months and fish deaths at around 18 months. The same January account rejected the pH stability previously reported during his positive presentation.

The archive also records his progression from suspecting silica nanoparticles in August 2022, with laboratory tests outstanding, to describing silicosis as a discovered cause in January 2025.

These are Hallam’s successive public accounts of the same experimental programme, preserved with their respective dates, wording and contexts.

February 2025: The public Facebook dispute

Le iAVs website published a response to Hallam’s statements on 27 February 2025. The article examined his claims concerning silica nanoparticles, microbial degradation of quartz, fish mortality, operating conditions and the duration of the original NCSU research.

Screenshots dated 28 February 2025 preserve a subsequent Facebook exchange involving the iAVs Official Website account, Murray Hallam’s Practical Aquaponics account and iAVs advocate Max Reed. The iAVs account challenged Hallam’s use of the term silicosis and linked to the February article.

Further questions addressed the proposed process by which microorganisms separated or released silica from quartz and requested documentation of the trout-farm incidents cited by Hallam.

Hallam’s visible reply concentrated on what he described as incorrect assumptions about his experimental system and himself personally. He objected to the tone of the criticism, referred to an unidentified keyboard critic and cited the achievements of his students and customers.

The screenshots also preserve responses accusing Hallam of evading the technical questions, together with a complaint that an earlier comment had been deleted. The exchange forms part of the archived history of the disagreement over Hallam’s silica explanation.

January 2026: Stephen Raisner repeats the silicosis explanation

The supplied evidence register records a further development on the Aquaponics Association forum in January 2026.

Stephen Raisner, the Potent Ponics operator who had previously interviewed Hallam about his sand-based experiment, stated:

Murray gave up sandponics after the fish got silicosis from the sand beds

This statement presented the alleged fish condition as the explanation for Hallam’s abandonment of sand-based cultivation. It also demonstrates the subsequent circulation of Hallam’s claim through another named aquaponics educator.

The same archive records a Facebook account identified as belonging to Stephen Raisner repeating the silica-related explanation, including additional references to “silica overdosing” and food-safety concerns. These later statements extend the documentary record beyond Hallam’s original experiment and into the wider circulation of the allegation within aquaponics discussions.

The January 2026 forum material and the Facebook records are identified in the supporting evidence ledger.

Quartz sand and the proposed biological mechanism

The technical documentation associated with iAVs describes quartz sand as a chemically stable medium suitable for filtration, biological activity and crop-root development. Quartz consists of silicon dioxide, SiO₂, arranged in a crystalline structure containing strong silicon–oxygen bonds. It has a hardness of 7 on the Mohs scale and is highly resistant to ordinary physical and chemical weathering.

Le iAVs Handbook records that clean quartz sand is chemically inert under normal system operating conditions and does not alter water pH. The sand’s stability, hydraulic characteristics and surface area are central to its use as a biological filtration medium.

Hallam’s proposed mechanism concerned microorganisms and fungi acting upon the sand and releasing silica into the circulating water. The relevant scientific distinction is between intact quartz grains, naturally dissolved silica, suspended mineral particles and manufactured silica nanoparticles.

Research on biological mineral weathering documents interactions between microorganisms and quartz surfaces. Research on engineered silica nanoparticles also documents biological effects under particular experimental conditions. The published toxicological literature includes studies of manufactured silica nanoparticles affecting fish tissues at defined exposure concentrations. Other studies have examined silica-based materials as aqueous additives, including experiments investigating their interaction with heavy-metal toxicity.

One example is Mahboub and colleagues’ 2022 study, Silica nanoparticles are novel aqueous additive mitigating heavy metals toxicity and improving the health of African catfish, Clarias gariepinus, published in Aquatic Toxicology, volume 249, article 106238.

PubMed record, PMID 35863252

These sources form part of the technical material assembled in response to Hallam’s claims.

Sand composition, carbonate contamination and ammonia

Le iAVs Handbook distinguishes quartz sand from sand containing reactive carbonate materials such as limestone or shell fragments.

Carbonates can raise water pH and alter ammonia toxicity.

The Handbook recommends testing prospective sand with vinegar to identify carbonate contamination through visible effervescence.

It also describes persistent increases in pH, particularly where pH repeatedly rebounds after correction, as a reason to examine the media for reactive carbonate content.

The distinction matters because ammonia exists in water in two principal forms: ammonium, NH₄⁺, and un-ionised ammonia, NH₃.

The proportion present as NH₃ increases with pH and temperature.

The supplied technical record gives the following values at 22°C: approximately 0.46% of total ammoniacal nitrogen in the un-ionised form at pH 7.0 and approximately 4.4% at pH 8.0.

It also identifies concentrations of un-ionised ammonia above 0.05 mg/L as potentially harmful to fish.

At the usual iAVs operating pH of approximately 6.4, a substantially smaller proportion of total ammonia is present as NH₃.

The original system design incorporates specified relationships between fish stocking, feed inputs, sand-bed area, plant growth, irrigation and drainage.

These parameters determine the biological loading of the filtration system and the conditions experienced by the fish.

The Handbook also addresses fine clay and silt fractions. Suspended mineral fines can cause physical problems, including gill irritation or obstruction. The specified sand grading therefore restricts excessive fine material.

These technical distinctions are documented separately from Hallam’s particular silica allegation.

Hallam’s experiment and the original NCSU methodology

Hallam repeatedly identified his experiment as being based on McMurtry’s research.

The recovered recordings describe approximately 35 m² of growing area and 125 mature jade perch weighing about two pounds each.

The earlier greenhouse tour recorded approximately 150 juvenile jade perch and modifications to the original fish tank.

The February 2025 iAVs investigation also examined features visible in Hallam’s installation, including fish stocking, plant composition, the use of a solids-lifting overflow, fish tank geometry and accumulated material within the sand furrows.

The original iAVs research specifies the relationship between fish biomass, nutrient input, sand-bed area and plant uptake.

Le iAVs guidance also addresses progressive fish harvesting, tank configuration, effective solids transport, crop distribution and irrigation frequency.

The February 2025 critique recorded departures from several of these recommendations in Hallam’s installation.

The analysis discussed the consequences of retaining substantial mature fish biomass, using a crop arrangement dominated by particular plant types and modifying water circulation or solids-handling arrangements.

These details are part of the documented technical dispute over Hallam’s implementation of McMurtry’s method.

Hallam’s criticism of the duration of NCSU research

In January 2025, Hallam claimed that McMurtry’s research had involved systems operating for approximately six months before results were published.

The historical record describes a broader experimental programme extending across several years.

The North Carolina State University research included multiple systems, replicated comparisons, different component ratios, crop trials, fish production measurements and studies of nutrient uptake and water efficiency.

Work originating in the mid-1980s led to publications in 1987, 1990 and later years.

The NCSU experimental programme included 16 systems, four component-ratio treatments and four replications, with three experiments conducted as part of the associated research.

McMurtry’s own account describes more than three years of active formal experimental research, in addition to earlier investigations.

These records document the extent of the original research programme alongside Hallam’s later description of its duration.

The relevant historical publications are available through the iAVs research archive.

Hallam, the Speraneo model and commercial aquaponics

The supplied historical material also places Hallam within the development of the commercial aquaponics industry.

Following the original iAVs research, Tom and Paula Speraneo developed and promoted a gravel-based variation known as bioponics.

The replacement of graded sand with gravel altered important physical and biological features of the original method.

Gravel and expanded-clay media subsequently became prominent in commercial and educational aquaponics systems.

The archive identifies Hallam and Sylvia Bernstein among the industry educators and kit suppliers associated with this broader media-bed model.

Hallam’s Practical Aquaponics business supplied instructional materials, equipment, training courses, system designs and consultations.

His February 2021 newsletter documents the incorporation of sand-based cultivation into that commercial educational programme.

The historical material also identifies Hallam’s connection with the early formation of the Aquaponics Association.

According to Sylvia Bernstein’s account, the August 2011 organising committee included Bernstein, Gina Cavaliero, Murray Hallam and Wayne Hall. The association was launched at the September conference.

This institutional history provides context for Hallam’s position within the industry when he began publicly discussing iAVs and, subsequently, the silica allegations.

Forum restrictions, copyright complaints and the wider dispute

Le iAVs archival material records a longer-running dispute concerning the presentation, attribution and promotion of McMurtry’s work within aquaponics communities. The Handbook describes restrictions on discussions of iAVs and McMurtry on the Backyard Aquaponics forum, which it identifies as associated with Hallam’s early industry network. Separate material documents disputes involving aquaponics educators, public video recordings, copyrighted material and the distribution of iAVs information.

In a forum post dated 23 January 2026, Stephen Raisner wrote:

Max has been sent DMCAs by myself, murray, and MyAquaponics.

The statement names Hallam among parties Raisner said had issued copyright complaints.

The archive also identifies a copyright claim involving material from the video Aquaponics & Flowering Crops with Murray Hallam at The Virtual Aquaponic Cannabis Conference. The disputed segment was identified as approximately 7:18–7:55.

Another archival item refers to an Aquaponics Association forum thread titled Video with Murray Hallam, in which a post was removed under a moderation description of “illegal”. The video, years later, is still online – https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PIqJhS3s2bA&t=8s this is yet evidence of the falsehoods being spread by grifters in the aquaponics industry.

The documentation places the silica controversy within a wider history of disputes involving educational recordings, attribution, publication rights and online discussion of iAVs.

The Alberta episode

The supplied investigative material also records an episode involving Hallam’s travel to Alberta, Canada.

According to the account preserved in the archive, Hallam travelled to Alberta while presenting himself as investigating iAVs, following encouragement from Gary Donaldson.

The account records that he did not contact McMurtry, who was living in neighbouring Montana.

McMurtry later commented on material associated with the visit, including a tomato plant visible in the background.

The episode appears in the wider correspondence concerning Hallam’s knowledge of iAVs, the relationship between commercial aquaponics advocates and the original researchers, and efforts to communicate McMurtry’s work.

It is preserved here as part of that historical correspondence.

Gary Donaldson’s and Mark McMurtry’s recorded assessments

The correspondence archive contains strongly worded assessments of Hallam by individuals involved in the development and preservation of iAVs.

Gary Donaldson, who worked extensively to promote and preserve McMurtry’s research, described Hallam as:

the ultimate willfully ignorant con

The same investigative material records Donaldson’s references to iAVs installations operating over periods of 25–35 years and longer.

McMurtry’s own comments also describe his dissatisfaction with Hallam’s treatment of the technology.

In a public comment dated 21 October 2024, McMurtry stated that Hallam had known of iAVs for decades and had chosen to promote what McMurtry considered erroneous and unsupported systems instead.

He referred to Donaldson’s repeated attempts to persuade Hallam to engage with the original research and criticised the commercial promotion of alternative aquaponics methods.

The personal-communications archive preserves additional comments.

In correspondence indexed, McMurtry described Hallam as:

Murray Hallam is an experienced professional conman.

He continued by criticising Hallam’s knowledge and understanding while commenting on his commercial and psychological effectiveness.

Elsewhere, McMurtry grouped Hallam with other industry personalities whom he accused of promoting commercially attractive but scientifically deficient approaches.

In correspondence, McMurtry referred to the commercial transformation of aquaponics and criticised the influence of Hallam and Bernstein.

His satirical Woo Masters Hall of Shame included Hallam under the description:

Brother Murray, Awesomely Amazing Aussy Anti-Factual

These passages are preserved as the personal assessments, criticism and satire of McMurtry and Donaldson.

They also demonstrate the intensity and longevity of disagreements between the original iAVs researchers and influential members of the commercial aquaponics industry.

The documentary status of the silica allegation

The accumulated record contains Hallam’s early endorsement of iAVs, his positive observations after approximately 22 months, his 2022 shutdown announcement, his 2025 explanation involving silicosis, and later repetitions of the allegation.

It also contains the technical response developed within the iAVs research and advocacy archive, including material on quartz chemistry, mineral weathering, nanoparticle toxicology, sand grading, ammonia toxicity and comparative system failures.

The following distinction appears throughout the records.

Hallam’s August 2022 statement explicitly identified silica nanoparticles as a suspected explanation and acknowledged that laboratory testing remained outstanding.

His January 2025 statement described silicosis as a problem that had been discovered and referred to a second installation in Canada as corroboration.

The supplied evidence compilation does not contain the laboratory report, fish pathology record, measured nanoparticle exposure or original trout-farm investigation underlying those later statements.

The associated source ledger contains the preserved social-media material, screenshots, URLs, transcripts, scientific references and correspondence supporting the chronology.

The historical account also includes direct criticism from the original inventor, contemporary exchanges with industry participants and later discussion within the Aquaponics Association.

Preservation of the historical record

The Hallam silica controversy developed over several years and across multiple platforms: Practical Aquaponics newsletters, greenhouse videos, podcast interviews, Facebook discussions, the iAVs website and the Aquaponics Association forum.

The chronology begins with Hallam publicly studying, implementing and endorsing McMurtry’s sand-based technology.

It continues through reported experimental success, declining production, system closure, a suspected silica nanoparticle problem and a subsequent claim of fish mortality from silicosis.

By January 2026, the explanation had been repeated by other participants in the aquaponics industry, including Stephen Raisner.

The accompanying technical record encompasses research on quartz stability, microbial weathering, silica nanoparticles, carbonate contamination, ammonia toxicity, system design and fish mortality in other sand-based installations.

The broader historical record documents relationships among Hallam, Bevan Suits, Sylvia Bernstein, Gary Donaldson, Stephen Raisner and Mark McMurtry, together with their roles in researching, teaching, promoting, modifying and disputing aquaponics technology.

These statements, documents, experiments and exchanges form the recorded history of the claim that silica released from sand caused fish deaths in Murray Hallam’s experimental iAVs installation.

Preserving the original wording, chronology, attribution and supporting materials enables that history to be examined through the accounts of the people directly involved.


Documentary sources and archival references

Murray Hallam, Practical Aquaponics. iAVS – Sand Ponics – Sand Gardening, 9 February 2021. Original newsletter.

Murray Hallam and Stephen Raisner. Growing With Fishes Podcast 179, Potent Ponics, 29 November 2019. Original recording.

Practical Aquaponics. Murray’s iAV Sand Aquaponics System et Practical Aquaponics Greenhouse Tour. Video 1 et Video 2.

Murray Hallam. Facebook statement concerning shutdown and suspected silica nanoparticles, 12 August 2022. Original post.

iAVs archive. Murray Hallam parle de iAVs. Archived transcript.

iAVs archive. Démystifier Murray Hallam : Science contre désinformation, 27 February 2025. Documentary compilation.

National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health. Silica and Worker Health. CDC reference.

Mahboub et al. Silica nanoparticles are novel aqueous additive mitigating heavy metals toxicity and improving the health of African catfish, Clarias gariepinus. Aquatic Toxicology 249 (2022), 106238. PubMed.

Additional archived records: archived Facebook screenshots and Aquaponics Association forum material.