বাণিজ্যিক স্যান্ডপোনিক্স ব্র্যান্ডিং কীভাবে বিজ্ঞানের ক্ষতি করছে, গবেষকদের বিভ্রান্ত করছে এবং একটি ওপেন-সোর্স আবিষ্কারকে আড়াল করছে

Leedana, Crops by SPC, CGIAR and Virginia Tech illustrate how the repeated misidentification of the Integrated Aqua-Vegeculture System has moved from commercial marketing into scientific research, university education and AI-generated information. Direct correspondence now documents the consequences.

Introduction: The damage is no longer hypothetical

For years, the original developers and advocates of the Integrated Aqua-Vegeculture System (iAVs) have raised concerns about an increasingly common practice: taking a scientifically established agricultural technology, promoting it under the ambiguous name “sandponics” and allowing its documented origins to disappear from public view.

The consequences are now documented.

In June 2026, a Virginia Tech professor acknowledged in writing that her research team had been using “sandponics” interchangeably with the Integrated Aqua-Vegeculture System in a manuscript they were preparing for publication.

The reason was particularly revealing.

The researchers had encountered the same conflation in recent peer-reviewed scientific literature.

Despite already knowing about Dr. Mark R. McMurtry’s work, they had not realised the terminology was incorrect.

The professor acknowledged the problem, agreed to correct the manuscript and contacted the university’s news department about correcting its public reporting.

This is direct evidence of an error propagating through the scientific information system.

A misleading identification had appeared in published research. University researchers encountered and adopted that terminology. Their subsequent work risked reproducing the same historical confusion until someone intervened.

The problem therefore extends far beyond a dispute about words.

It concerns the integrity of scientific literature, the education of future researchers, the accuracy of agricultural instruction and public access to a technology deliberately shared for the benefit of humanity.

Two contemporary commercial businesses, Leedana and SPC for Advanced Agriculture, provide important examples of how the same technology is promoted under another identity.

Their activities also raise a second question.

What happens when a freely shared agricultural invention becomes more visible through commercial branding than through the scientific work that made those businesses possible?

That question deserves a direct examination.

1. The original invention: Integrated Aqua-Vegeculture System

The Integrated Aqua-Vegeculture System was developed by Dr. Mark R. McMurtry and a multidisciplinary research group at North Carolina State University during the 1980s.

Published evidence includes:

1987: McMurtry, Nelson and Sanders presented research on vegetable production using recirculated aquaculture water in HortScience.

1990: McMurtry, Nelson, Sanders and Hodges published পুনঃসঞ্চালিত মৎস্য চাষের বর্জ্য জল ব্যবহার করে বালিতে সবজি চাষ, documenting the integration of fish production and vegetable cultivation without supplemental fertilizer.

1997: McMurtry and colleagues published research examining the productivity of different biofilter-to-fish-tank ratios and the efficiency of water use in integrated fish and vegetable production.

The 1997 water-use research identified the sand beds as biological filters, plant-growing substrates and sites for the oxidation of organic solids.

These were established characteristics of iAVs before the contemporary businesses discussed here existed.

The historical record is not obscure because the research never happened.

It has become obscure because much of the subsequent publicity and literature fails to connect the technology to that research.

Original 1990 research

1997 biofilter-ratio research

1997 water-use efficiency research

2. The technology was deliberately made available to everyone

An essential part of the iAVs history is the decision to share the technology freely.

McMurtry developed the system with the intention of making efficient food production accessible to people facing water scarcity, poverty and food insecurity.

The approach was designed around biological efficiency and practical simplicity.

It was intended to reduce unnecessary infrastructure and dependence upon costly external inputs.

According to McMurtry’s historical account, the invention was declared available for open use in 1985, and he recovered the associated invention rights in December 1989.

The surviving history of TULCO, the university-associated technology-transfer organisation, records the difficulties surrounding those rights and McMurtry’s determination to preserve public access.

The original development was not intended to create a permanent commercial gatekeeper between farmers and the knowledge required to grow food.

That principle remains central to iAVs.info.

The volunteer, non-commercial educational project provides research history, instructional materials, publications, technical guidance and assistance to growers and researchers internationally.

The objective is to make the original technology accessible without requiring people to purchase proprietary farming packages.

Commercial businesses can legitimately build upon this foundation.

They may sell greenhouse structures, monitoring software, installation services, management expertise or produce.

But those commercial offerings are separate from the underlying invention.

A business that successfully commercialises iAVs has achieved something different from inventing iAVs.

Both contributions can be recognised without confusing them.

The scientific history belongs to the original research. The commercial achievements belong to those who subsequently implement and develop the technology.

That distinction should never be difficult for an educational institution, research organisation or responsible agricultural business to explain.

3. The term “sandponics” already belonged to a different scientific history

The ambiguity surrounding “sandponics” is not a matter of personal preference.

The term was already associated with a separate Japanese cultivation technology developed by Sumitomo Electric Industries during the 1970s.

Its historical development was described by Masato Baba and Naoki Ikeguchi in their 2015 technical paper, Industrial Cultivation Using the Latest Sandponics System.

That technology involved growing plants in sand using supplied nutrient solutions.

It was not the same integrated fish-waste treatment and vegetable production system developed at NCSU.

The name SANDPONICS was subsequently registered as a trademark in the United States for specified agricultural goods and services.

Another independently documented use appears in research by Makokha and colleagues concerning sweet-potato vine multiplication.

Their 2018 study used sand and mineral fertilizer solutions to investigate optimal plant nutrition.

There were no fish supplying the nutrients.

Nevertheless, the researchers called the method “sandponics.”

These are different cultivation systems operating under the same label.

One employs externally supplied fertilizer solutions.

Another is a fish-integrated, biologically functioning agricultural system.

Their nutrient sources, management requirements and scientific conclusions cannot automatically be transferred between them.

Calling both technologies “sandponics” destroys an important technical distinction.

The original NCSU technology already has a documented name: Integrated Aqua-Vegeculture System.

That name identifies the invention, its research history and its original operating principles.

Sumitomo Electric research, 2015

Makokha et al., 2018

4. The error enters peer-reviewed literature

A significant example appeared in Scientific Reports in June 2022.

Hani Sewilam and colleagues published:

A sandponics comparative study investigating different sand media based integrated aqua vegeculture systems using desalinated water.

The paper described a fish-integrated sand cultivation system and treated “sandponics” as an alternative name for iAVs.

It also described the approach as relatively under-researched, despite the existence of the earlier NCSU programme.

The study itself investigated Swiss chard production using fish effluent and different sand media.

Its measurements may offer useful information about the particular experimental arrangements.

The historical problem concerns the identification of the underlying technology and its relationship to earlier research.

When authors treat an established scientific system as though it is interchangeable with an ambiguous label, they introduce confusion into the literature that subsequent researchers depend upon.

Future authors may encounter the newer terminology, reproduce it in their literature reviews and gradually lose the connection to the original scientific work.

The problem can persist even when nobody intends to misattribute an invention.

Peer review does not automatically protect against this.

A journal may review experimental methods, statistical analysis and results while failing to recognise that the historical identification of the technology is incomplete or misleading.

The published article then becomes a reference for subsequent studies.

An error appearing in a peer-reviewed publication is still an error. Repetition does not correct it.

Scientific Reports, Sewilam et al., 2022

5. Virginia Tech: direct evidence that the conflation damaged the research record

The strongest documented example comes from Virginia Tech.

It illustrates precisely how inaccurate terminology can travel from one body of literature into another research programme.

The 2024 university research abstract

Virginia Tech’s 2024 Summer Research Conference included an abstract entitled:

Sandponics: A new approach to traditional nitrification and solids removal processes in aquaponics systems.

The researchers investigated sand media as alternatives to expanded-clay growing media in aquaponic systems.

They examined the possibility of using sand for solids retention and biological filtration, thereby reducing the need for separate treatment equipment.

The abstract described these functions as an innovative approach.

Yet the NCSU researchers had already investigated and published the integration of sand filtration, fish production and vegetable cultivation decades earlier.

The Virginia Tech experiment could legitimately examine new materials, compare different sand sources or test alternative arrangements.

Those would be valid research objectives.

But the underlying principle of using biologically active sand beds to treat fish water while growing crops was already established.

Presenting that principle as a new approach without clearly connecting it to its original development leaves readers with an incomplete historical account.

The abstract also illustrates the danger of imprecise technical descriptions. It refers to expected denitrification, whereas nitrification and denitrification are different nitrogen transformations with different biological requirements and consequences.

These distinctions matter in systems containing live fish.

Virginia Tech 2024 Summer Research Conference Abstract Book, pages 197–198

The 2026 university publicity

On 17 May 2026, Virginia Tech published a news feature describing research into sand-based aquaponics for water-scarce regions.

The reporting presented sand as an inexpensive alternative to synthetic growing media and discussed the possibility of simplifying integrated fish-and-vegetable systems.

The article and associated publicity used the sandponics terminology.

The same fundamental filtration and nutrient-recycling functions had been investigated at NCSU decades earlier.

The reporting also referred to sweet-potato research, raising the possibility of confusion with the separate mineral-fertigation studies conducted by Makokha and colleagues.

This was not simply a question of an incorrect name in a headline.

The broader account risked presenting familiar principles as newly emerging while failing to explain the original research adequately.

Virginia Tech coverage, reproduced by HortiDaily

The research team confirms the problem

In June 2026, iAVs.info contacted Virginia Tech to explain the historical and technical concerns.

Dr. Natasha Bell, Assistant Professor in the Department of Biological Systems Engineering, responded in correspondence retained by iAVs Research and Education.

She acknowledged that the research team had already been familiar with McMurtry’s work.

Nevertheless, the researchers had used the two names interchangeably in a draft manuscript.

Most importantly, Bell explicitly explained that the practice had been influenced by recent peer-reviewed literature.

Her response stated:

“We did not realize that it was incorrect to use the term ‘sandponics’ interchangeably with ‘integrated aqua-vegeculture system'”

She also acknowledged:

“As you mentioned, in recent peer-reviewed literature, we’d noticed that authors are indeed interchangeably using those terms.”

These admissions establish an actual instance of terminology being carried from published scientific literature into new scientific writing.

It was not a hypothetical concern.

It had reached an active research manuscript.

Bell confirmed that her team intended to correct the terminology and give appropriate credit to McMurtry and the original researchers.

She also reported that Virginia Tech’s news department was willing to revise the public article.

The response was constructive and demonstrated professional willingness to correct the record.

That should be recognised.

But the fact that the correction was necessary is the central issue.

Researchers at a major American university, working directly on a technology developed at another American university, had absorbed a misleading identification of the system from contemporary scientific publications.

The research programme did not require those errors to be repeated.

It required better access to the original literature and clearer scientific attribution.

This is a documented breakdown in the transmission of scientific knowledge.

The technical information that had been overlooked

The subsequent correspondence also addressed several engineering and biological details from the original NCSU research.

These included the importance of sand characteristics, the effects of biological activity on nutrient retention, the significance of furrows and ridges, appropriate nutrient loading and the management of oxygen within the sand beds.

The NCSU research had investigated spatial changes within the growing medium rather than treating sand as a uniform, inert substrate.

Its researchers collected samples at different depths and distances from the irrigation furrows to examine changing chemical characteristics.

The original design also depended on intermittent irrigation and drainage to maintain aerobic conditions.

These are important operating considerations.

If a researcher encounters the technology only through simplified descriptions of sandponics, these earlier findings may never enter the experimental design.

That can lead to unnecessary repetition of earlier work or comparisons that fail to account for important variables.

In a live aquaculture system, inappropriate sand, hydraulic loading or oxygen conditions can have serious biological consequences.

The Virginia Tech correspondence does not establish that the project suffered fish mortality or equipment failure.

It does establish that researchers required clarification about the established technology and its technical history.

The damage documented here is to research accuracy, attribution and the continuity of technical knowledge. That is already significant.

6. Leedana: knowing the original name but continuing to promote another

Leedana provides a different example.

The Canadian agricultural business, founded by Hassan Elrakhawy, is associated with McGill University’s entrepreneurship ecosystem.

It promotes integrated fish-and-sand agriculture as sandponics, alongside proprietary software, farm-management systems and commercial implementation services.

McGill publicity has described the business as developing sustainable agricultural production in desert environments.

The issue is not whether Leedana can operate successful farms.

The issue is whether it consistently distinguishes its commercial developments from the original NCSU invention.

The McGill article and subsequent correction

On 26 May 2025, the McGill Reporter published an article promoting Leedana’s agricultural work under the sandponics name.

The article prompted concerns about the presentation of the technology’s origins.

McGill subsequently corrected the main article.

Its revised introduction now identifies the method as the Integrated Aqua Vegeculture System and credits McMurtry and his NCSU colleagues.

That correction was important and appropriate.

However, another article published through McGill Desautels on 5 June 2025 continued describing Leedana’s work using the sandponics name without explaining the original invention.

The result was inconsistent institutional reporting.

Readers encountering one university publication could find the correct historical information.

Readers encountering another could remain unaware of it.

For an institution involved in research and higher education, this inconsistency is difficult to justify.

Corrected McGill Reporter article

McGill Desautels article

Leedana’s own acknowledgment

In correspondence dated 28 June 2025, Hassan Elrakhawy acknowledged that iAVs was the correct name and that his company had not managed the transition from sandponics adequately.

He recognised McMurtry’s foundational work and indicated that Leedana would continue correcting its terminology.

His response also described the commercial and communication difficulties of introducing a less familiar scientific name into markets where sandponics had become widely used.

He argued that the newer name was easier for some farmers to understand and that local-language variations had already become familiar.

These explanations reveal the underlying conflict.

A business finds one term commercially convenient.

The scientific record identifies another term as the established name of the technology.

The business then faces a choice between preserving the familiar marketing label and consistently educating its audience about the original invention.

That choice has consequences.

Once a company knows the documented history, continuing to promote an ambiguous term without prominent clarification becomes an editorial decision, not merely an innocent misunderstanding.

The commercial convenience of a label does not outweigh the importance of correct attribution.

What Leedana’s public website reveals

Leedana’s technology page describes systems where fish waste fertilises crops grown in sand, followed by drainage and water recirculation.

These are fundamental iAVs principles.

The company acknowledges that its work builds upon earlier open-source research, including iAVs.

Its community page also identifies McMurtry and his team as the original inventors and directs readers toward educational materials.

Those acknowledgments are meaningful.

But elsewhere, the company continues to use sandponics as its primary technological identity.

It also promotes its own specialised growing medium, software and commercial farm network.

These commercial services may offer genuine value.

They do not change the origin of the underlying biological method.

The public presentation would be substantially clearer if the technology were consistently identified as iAVs, with Leedana’s adaptations and commercial products described separately.

A contradiction within Leedana’s educational resources

A particularly important example appears on Leedana’s own community page.

The page recommends both the 2022 fish-integrated study by Sewilam and the 2018 sweet-potato study by Makokha.

But the Makokha study investigated sand cultivation using externally supplied fertilizer solutions.

It did not study the integrated aquaculture nutrient cycle that defines iAVs.

Presenting both publications within a common sandponics educational category, without clearly explaining their differences, risks teaching readers that fundamentally different nutrient-management systems belong to the same technical method.

This is precisely the sort of confusion the iAVs terminology was intended to prevent.

Leedana’s wider farm-network material also includes sandponics projects without fish tanks.

Such projects may be valid sand-based cultivation systems.

But they should not automatically be identified as iAVs.

The company’s own material demonstrates that its use of sandponics covers a wider range of technologies than the original Integrated Aqua-Vegeculture System.

One label is being used for methods with materially different operating principles. That is unsuitable as a precise scientific identification.

7. SPC for Advanced Agriculture: commercialising the technology under another identity

SPC for Advanced Agriculture, also known as The Sandponic Collective, operates in Egypt and promotes commercial systems combining fish cultivation with vegetables grown in sand.

Its produce is marketed under the Crops brand.

The company presents sandponics as an innovative agricultural solution for water scarcity, food security and sustainable production.

Its public business materials describe turnkey farm installation, management, quality supervision, produce packaging and commercial distribution.

These services reflect a commercial implementation model.

However, the underlying biological principles closely resemble those developed and investigated in the NCSU iAVs research.

SPC’s website prominently uses the sandponics name and discusses its own standards and agricultural innovations.

The public pages examined for this article do not prominently identify the original NCSU researchers or establish the distinction between the foundational technology and SPC’s subsequent commercial contributions.

That omission matters.

The company may have improved construction practices, management procedures, local operating methods or commercial distribution.

Those achievements should be described accurately.

But they must not be confused with the original invention of fish-integrated sand biofiltration for vegetable production.

Commercial adaptation is not independent invention. Changing the name does not change the origin.

SPC company information

SPC commercial services

8. CGIAR: institutional authority amplifying an incomplete history

The consequences become more serious when internationally recognised research institutions repeat incomplete descriptions.

In 2026, the CGIAR Accelerate for Impact Platform featured SPC through its AgriTech4Tunisia Innovation Spotlight programme.

The feature described SPC’s sandponics system as an agricultural innovation combining aquaculture and crop production.

It explained that sand served as a natural biological filter and that the water was recycled.

These are central characteristics of the original NCSU iAVs নকশা।.

Yet the feature did not identify the NCSU research group as the original developers of the integrated technology.

Instead, the emphasis fell upon SPC’s commercial achievements and its development through the CGIAR-supported innovation programme.

The promotion included figures such as 127 tonnes of annual crop production, 16 tonnes of fish, 12 deployed farms or projects and water savings claimed to reach 95%.

These figures were presented by the programme and business. They should be distinguished from independently audited experimental results.

The issue is not that CGIAR featured an agricultural business.

Supporting new enterprises can contribute to food security and economic development.

The issue is that a major international research partnership described an established technology without properly connecting its audience to the original scientific literature.

CGIAR has substantial influence among researchers, development agencies, educational institutions and agricultural policymakers.

Its promotional material may become a reference for people who have never encountered the original NCSU work.

When an institution with that level of scientific credibility overlooks the documented provenance of a technology, it helps perpetuate the very confusion that university research and peer review should prevent.

Institutional authority brings institutional responsibility.

CGIAR/A4IP SPC Innovation Spotlight

9. The shared consequence: commercial visibility replaces scientific provenance

Leedana and SPC are not identical businesses, and the available evidence does not establish that either company individually caused Virginia Tech’s terminology error.

But their public communications demonstrate the same wider problem documented in the scientific literature.

An established technology is promoted under a more marketable or familiar label.

The original research is omitted, subordinated or inconsistently acknowledged.

University publicity repeats the commercial terminology.

Academic authors encounter and reproduce that terminology.

Subsequent readers increasingly associate the technology with recent commercial activity rather than its documented invention.

That is how scientific history becomes distorted.

No conspiracy is required.

The process can emerge through commercial incentives, inadequate literature reviews, careless publicity, editorial repetition and institutional failure to verify technical claims.

But the absence of a demonstrated conspiracy does not remove responsibility for the resulting errors.

Once the historical evidence is available, continuing to omit or obscure it becomes harder to justify.

The obligation to correct the record grows stronger, not weaker, as the publication or organisation becomes more influential.

10. What this means for students

A student approaching the subject should be able to identify the correct scientific literature before designing an experiment or building a system.

That requires more than finding a collection of articles using the same popular label.

It requires distinguishing which studies actually investigate iAVs and which investigate unrelated sand-growing methods.

A student who searches only for sandponics may encounter fertilizer-based sweet-potato propagation, commercial greenhouse systems, modified aquaponics installations and original iAVs-type designs without realising that their operating requirements differ.

The student may then compare results that are not technically equivalent.

Important variables may be overlooked, including sand characteristics, hydraulic loading, nutrient sources, oxygen availability, biological filtration, planting arrangements and fish-feed input.

This is not a harmless naming problem.

It can affect the quality of a literature review, the relevance of selected methods and the interpretation of experimental findings.

The Virginia Tech correspondence demonstrates that this problem can occur even among researchers who are already familiar with the original inventor.

Students without that prior knowledge are even more dependent upon accurate published information.

11. What this means for growers

The consequences for growers can be practical and costly.

The original iAVs research provides guidance on the coordinated operation of fish and plant components.

Its operating principles include the appropriate sand medium, intermittent irrigation, complete drainage, the use of furrows and ridges, and the management of nutrient inputs according to crop production.

These factors influence oxygen availability, microbial activity, nutrient cycling and system stability.

A grower who encounters a simplified sandponics description may not learn why these design details matter.

They may use unsuitable sand, apply inappropriate nutrient-loading rates or follow recommendations drawn from unrelated hydroponic studies.

The results may be poor plant growth, unstable water quality, inadequate filtration or avoidable management difficulties.

In severe cases, mistakes affecting oxygen availability or nitrogen metabolism can threaten fish survival.

Such risks are well recognised in aquaculture.

The original iAVs instructions are therefore more than historical curiosities.

They provide the engineering and biological context needed to understand why the method works.

It is irresponsible to promote an integrated biological system while obscuring the technical research required to reproduce it reliably.

12. The commercialisation problem: charging for services around a freely available invention

The distinction between open knowledge and proprietary services deserves particular attention.

Leedana promotes proprietary software for monitoring and managing commercial agricultural systems.

SPC offers turnkey farm installation, supervision and produce marketing.

These may be legitimate and useful services.

But the original iAVs method does not require a commercial software subscription, exclusive consultancy agreement or branded farm package.

The technology was developed around relatively simple infrastructure and biological processes.

Growers should know that distinction before deciding whether to purchase commercial assistance.

A person who wants professional installation may benefit from a commercial supplier.

Another person may have the skills and local materials needed to build a smaller installation independently.

Both should have access to the original scientific knowledge.

The danger arises when the public encounters only the commercial presentation and never discovers the freely available research.

That can produce an artificial dependence on paid services or proprietary explanations.

It can also discourage independent experimentation and community-led adoption.

This is particularly troubling for a technology whose original purpose included helping resource-limited communities achieve greater food security.

The commercialisation of open knowledge should increase accessibility.

It should not make freely available science harder to identify, understand or use.

13. Artificial intelligence is now repeating the same error

The spread of the sandponics terminology has also affected automated information systems.

On 15 October 2026, a Google search concerning Crops by SPC generated an AI Overview describing the business and its sandponics technology.

The summary explained the company’s agricultural activities and commercial recognition.

It did not connect the technology to the original NCSU iAVs research.

This demonstrates another stage in the propagation of incomplete information.

Search engines and large language models draw upon websites, publications, institutional news, promotional material and other sources.

When the available material repeatedly uses ambiguous terminology, automated systems may reproduce it without recovering the correct historical context.

The resulting explanations can appear authoritative to readers.

An agricultural technology developed in the 1980s may consequently be presented through the language of a contemporary business.

The original research becomes less visible.

The newer terminology becomes more common.

Future automated summaries may then repeat the same incomplete account.

This creates a self-reinforcing information problem.

The number of websites repeating a claim does not establish the historical accuracy of that claim.

For iAVs, the authoritative starting point remains the documented NCSU research.

Artificial intelligence should help people locate scientific knowledge, not bury original research beneath accumulated marketing terminology.

14. The responsibility of commercial businesses and scientific institutions

The historical record imposes clear responsibilities upon those publishing information about this technology.

Businesses implementing iAVs should identify the original invention and explain what they have independently contributed.

Universities should establish scientific provenance before celebrating a technology as innovative or newly developed.

Journal editors and peer reviewers should ensure that relevant foundational research is identified.

Researchers should distinguish the methods actually used in their experiments from those employed in superficially similar systems.

Development agencies should connect promoted agricultural technologies to their established research histories.

These obligations are particularly important when a technology was deliberately made available for public benefit.

Repeatedly presenting an open invention through commercial branding without adequately identifying its origins is a failure of attribution.

Describing known biological functions as new without acknowledging the previous experiments is a failure of historical scholarship.

Using a common name for technically incompatible systems without explaining the differences is a failure of scientific communication.

The Virginia Tech example demonstrates that these failures can propagate directly into research manuscripts.

That consequence is documented, not speculative.

The fact that its researchers responded constructively provides an example of how the problem can be corrected.

But individual corrections cannot substitute for consistent standards across the wider research and commercial community.

15. What an accurate description should say

When referring to the fish-integrated sand-bed method developed at NCSU, the proper identification is:

Integrated Aqua-Vegeculture System (iAVs), developed by Dr. Mark R. McMurtry and the multidisciplinary iAVs research group at North Carolina State University beginning in the mid-1980s.

The technology integrates aquaculture with vegetable production through intermittently irrigated sand beds that provide mechanical filtration, biological filtration, organic solids mineralisation and a growing medium for crops.

Contemporary commercial systems based upon these principles should identify their relationship to iAVs.

Where significant modifications have been introduced, those modifications should be described separately and supported with appropriate technical evidence.

Where the term sandponics is used, publications should distinguish the particular method from unrelated fertilizer-based sand cultivation.

Accurate terminology makes the original research discoverable.

It allows later experiments to be evaluated against the established baseline.

It enables growers to locate the correct instructional materials.

And it preserves the ability of future researchers to distinguish genuine innovation from the implementation of existing knowledge.

Conclusion: Scientific knowledge must not be buried beneath commercial branding

The Integrated Aqua-Vegeculture System was invented and scientifically developed decades before the emergence of contemporary sandponics businesses.

Its research history is documented.

Its operating principles were investigated.

Its findings were published.

Its inventor intended the technology to be shared widely, particularly with people who could benefit from affordable and water-efficient food production.

Yet the same fundamental method is now frequently encountered through commercial brands and publications that call it sandponics.

Leedana demonstrates how a company can acknowledge the original inventors while continuing to promote the underlying approach under another primary identity.

SPC demonstrates how a fish-integrated sand system can be commercially promoted without prominently identifying the NCSU research on which its core principles are based.

CGIAR demonstrates how institutional promotion can give international visibility to an incomplete historical account.

And Virginia Tech provides direct evidence that the confusion has entered scientific research communications and draft manuscripts.

The Virginia Tech case is particularly important because it establishes that the consequences extend beyond public perception.

The original literature was already being displaced by inconsistent terminology in a subsequent research programme.

The scientific record was being reproduced inaccurately until the problem was brought to the researchers’ attention.

That is a failure of knowledge transfer.

It is a failure that consumes educational and research effort, obscures relevant findings and risks depriving future growers of the information required to implement the technology correctly.

The people who developed iAVs did the scientific work. They investigated the design. They documented the results. They shared the knowledge.

Their work should not become difficult to find because subsequent businesses and institutions prefer another name.

The right of a company to commercialise an openly shared technology does not entitle it to rewrite the history of the invention.

Nor does the marketing convenience of an ambiguous term justify perpetuating confusion in the scientific literature.

For students, researchers and growers, the fundamental issue is access to accurate knowledge.

For the original developers, it is recognition of documented scientific contributions.

For communities facing water scarcity and food insecurity, it is the ability to discover and use the technology without unnecessary commercial barriers.

These are connected responsibilities.

The correct name is Integrated Aqua-Vegeculture System (iAVs).

The original development belongs to Dr. Mark R. McMurtry and the North Carolina State University iAVs research group.

Its foundational knowledge was made available for public benefit and remains accessible through iAVs Research and Education.

The historical record will not be preserved by allowing inaccurate terminology to spread unchallenged.

It must be corrected wherever the error appears: in commercial publications, university publicity, peer-reviewed research, development programmes and automated information systems.

The purpose is not to prevent commercial participation.

It is to ensure that commercial participation does not erase the science that made it possible.

And it is to protect the original promise of iAVs: an agricultural technology developed to help people produce food, conserve water and access knowledge freely.


Sources and documentary record

Foundational scientific research

McMurtry, M. R., Nelson, P. V., Sanders, D. C., and Hodges, L. (1990). Sand Culture of Vegetables Using Recirculated Aquacultural Effluents. Applied Agricultural Research, 5(4), 280–284.

McMurtry, M. R., Sanders, D. C., Cure, J. D., and Hodson, R. G. (1997). Effects of Biofilter/Culture Tank Volume Ratios on Productivity of a Recirculating Fish/Vegetable Co-Culture System. Journal of Applied Aquaculture, 7(4), 33–51. https://doi.org/10.1300/J028v07n04_03

McMurtry, M. R., Sanders, D. C., Cure, J. D., Hodson, R. G., Haning, B. C., and St. Amand, P. C. (1997). Efficiency of Water Use of an Integrated Fish/Vegetable Co-Culture System. Journal of the World Aquaculture Society, 28(4), 420–428. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1749-7345.1997.tb00290.x

Terminology and subsequent research

Baba, M., and Ikeguchi, N. (2015). Industrial Cultivation Using the Latest Sandponics System. SEI Technical Review, 80. https://sumitomoelectric.com/sites/default/files/2020-12/download_documents/80-21.pdf

Makokha, P., et al. (2018). Optimization of nutrient media for sweetpotato vine multiplication in sandponics. Gates Open Research, 2:59. https://doi.org/10.12688/gatesopenres.12879.1

Sewilam, H., Kimera, F., Nasr, P., and Dawood, M. (2022). A sandponics comparative study investigating different sand media based integrated aqua vegeculture systems using desalinated water. Scientific Reports, 12, 11093. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-022-15291-7

Virginia Tech

Virginia Tech (2024). Summer Research Conference Abstract Book. Contains the sandponics research abstract supervised by Natasha Bell. Original university document.

Virginia Tech (17 May 2026). Sand-based aquaponics system offers more affordable path for farming in water-scarce regions. Republished coverage.

iAVs Research and Education (June 2026). Correspondence with Dr. Natasha Bell, Department of Biological Systems Engineering, Virginia Tech. Original correspondence retained in the iAVs historical archive. Selected statements reproduced in this article.

Leedana and McGill

McGill Reporter (26 May 2025). McGill-linked startup grows vegetables sustainably in the desert.

McGill Desautels (5 June 2025). Leedana is bringing agriculture to the desert.

Leedana. Sandponics Technology, Community Resources এবং Global Farm Network.

iAVs Research and Education (June 2025). Correspondence with Hassan Elrakhawy, CEO of Leedana. Original correspondence retained in the iAVs historical archive.

SPC and CGIAR

SPC for Advanced Agriculture. Company Information এবং Commercial Services.

CGIAR Accelerate for Impact Platform (2026). AgriTech4Tunisia Innovation Spotlight: SPC for Advanced Agriculture.

iAVs historical and educational resources

iAVs Research and Education

Sandponics is NOT iAVs

TULCO and the Open-Source Gift